Image source: Allie Crewe Photography

Warning: This article contains references to sexual violence and harassment.

When Joan Young woke up, she was tied to her own bed.

He did not know what happened to him during unconsciousness.

Then she heard her then-husband Philip Young say to another man, "Get down."

Joan immediately understood that apart from the two of them, there was someone else present in the bedroom.

But even at that time she had no idea that her husband had invited other men to sexually exploit her by giving advertisements on the internet.

Philip Young used to make him unconscious by giving him drugs. He would then invite strange men into the bedroom, where they would sexually assault Joan.

All this was going on for 13 years.

End

The court convicted these four people

Image source: Wiltshire Police

Last Thursday, i.e. on November 19, the court found four men guilty of several crimes including raping Joan and sexually assaulting her.

Joan's ex-husband Philip Young had already admitted several rape charges.

Former Conservative Party councilor Philip Young and another man, Dean Hamilton, had pleaded guilty to rape and sexual assault charges at a previous hearing.

The men involved in this case worked in different jobs and came from different backgrounds.

One of these people worked on the nuclear defense project of the British Defense Ministry. Another man used to travel to Romania driving Red Cross trucks in the 1980s.

'The one whom you trusted the most betrayed you'

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

After the verdict, Joan said outside the court that she is living with such pain which is difficult to explain in words.

But she is trying to rebuild her life.

Giving a message to people who have experienced sexual violence, she said, "You are not alone."

Joan said, "Today's guilty verdict is a relief. This relief is not only for me and my family, but also for what it will mean for other women in the future."

"This decision means that people facing a situation like mine will now have the courage to put forward their views. Their confidence in the criminal justice system will also increase."

Joan said that it has been very difficult to understand and accept what happened to her without her knowledge or consent.

She says, "This harassment took away from me the life I loved."

"The person I trusted the most in the world betrayed me in the most horrific way. This has had a devastating impact on my life and the lives of my children."

Joan said that there was not just one person responsible for what happened to her. "Other people were also invited to participate and did so of their own free will."

"I am living with a pain that is difficult to describe in words. Its impact will be on our lives forever. It is scary to even think that this could happen to someone."

Joan said, "If we really want to stop this type of harassment, remaining silent is not the way to go."

An incident like the Giselle Pellico case of France

Joan's case has many similarities to the repeated rape of Giselle Pellico of France.

Experts have called it a very serious and exploitative crime.

Philip Young used to present this sexual violence on the Internet as a shared sexual choice between husband and wife. This is called 'cuckolding'.

Joan's photos were used in advertisements placed on websites like Craigslist and Grindr.

In these pictures, she was seen tied to the bed in an unconscious state.

James Foster, special prosecutor of the Crown Prosecution Service, or CPS, Britain's government prosecution agency, said that Philip Young used to give drugs to Joan.

After this he used to sexually exploit Joan and also record it.

He also invited other men to his home so that they could sexually assault Joan.

Dean Hamilton came after seeing the advertisement

Among the men who saw this advertisement on the Internet was 46-year-old Dean Hamilton.

He admitted that in 2015 he raped and sexually assaulted Joan.

The other men convicted of sexually abusing Joan include 32-year-old Connor Sanderson-Doyle, 62-year-old Richard Wilkins, 48-year-old Norman McSoney and 38-year-old Mohammed Hassan.

Mohammed Hassan was the same person to whom Philip Young told Joan to "get down" when she opened her eyes.

These men told the court that they thought that both Joan and Philip Young had agreed to all this.

He said that he was told that Joan was pretending to sleep.

But in reality Joan was rendered unconscious by giving her a huge amount of drugs.

James Foster said, "During this entire harassment he never once asked Joan Young what she wanted."

"He didn't even make any effort to find out what Joan's wishes were."

What does consent mean?

According to the law, consent to sexual intercourse can be considered only when a person is ready for it by his own choice.

That person should also have the freedom and understanding to take this decision.

Investigators are asked to determine whether the suspect took any steps to obtain the consent of the complainant.

Marian Hester, Emeritus Professor at Bristol University, said that Joan was clearly in no position to deny.

"If a woman is sleeping, she cannot give consent," she says.

"The same applies if a woman has been drugged and completely unconscious. She cannot decide whether to consent to sex."

'Questions have to be raised on the thinking of men'

Professor Marianne Hester has been researching gender-related violence for many years.

He says that such cases raise big questions on society's thinking regarding women and sexual relations.

She says, "We have to question men and their thinking. We have to ask why men think it is okay to have sex this way."

"These extremely exploitative practices within sexual relationships are being normalized again and again. We are also normalizing them. This is a very serious problem."

Hester said that investigation of some websites has already started.

He said, "In many different countries, people have been identified who have been doing exactly the same thing."

"So I think there may be many more such cases in the future."

Questions on the role of websites

After this case, questions have also been raised on the role of those websites which were used for such harassment.

Lisa Sugiura, professor of cybercrime and gender at the University of Portsmouth, says online platforms have a responsibility to tackle content that normalizes violence against women.

"Photographic harassment and extremely violent language against women often appears on these websites," she said.

Such things are also written on these forums about women, which promote violence.

Lisa Sugiura says, “The question then arises, how are these online platforms allowed to operate like this without any monitoring and accountability?”

"The question that comes after that is whether we should accept as true the words of a man who is claiming to speak on behalf of himself and his wife."

Hundreds of possible cases investigated in Britain

Image source: Reuters/Jack Taylor

Statistics show that hundreds of such potential crimes are under investigation in Britain.

Britain's National Crime Agency or NCA has said that there is an urgent need to deal with this problem at the international level.

NCA investigators have identified more than 270 people linked to an online forum and the groups that followed it.

CPS has described such crimes as a new emerging challenge for the investigating agencies.

James Foster said, "In this particular type of crime, the husband drugs his wife, sexually abuses her, and also invites other men to exploit her."

"It seems like this is a new method of crime."

Why is it not known how many cases there are?

A spokesman for Wiltshire Police said that the exact number of drug-related rapes is not known.

One reason for this is that many victims do not even know that they were targeted.

"Organized drug-related sexual assaults are less common than other forms of sexual crimes," the spokesperson said.

"But the information we have and other recent cases indicate that many such crimes go unreported."

He said victims often did not know they had been drugged.

They may have fragmented memories of the incident. Many times they initially mistake its symptoms for the effects of drinking alcohol.

"These factors make it very difficult to detect and report such crimes," the spokesperson said.

'Crime is not new, technology made it easier'

Image source, Reuters

Lisa Sugiura does not agree that this type of crime in itself is new.

They believe that technology has made it easier to commit and hide such harassment. This type of harassment has probably been going on for many years.

She says, "Technology allows people to hide their identity. With this they can create two separate identities."

"They maintain their respectable image in the offline world and commit such heinous crimes online."

According to them, criminals often operate within large online communities where misogynistic views are promoted and harassing material is shared.

"These are not always isolated incidents," she says.

"They may be part of a larger network, where people tell each other about methods, encourage each other to do so, and share material about very serious forms of abuse against women."

He said, "I think many more such cases may come to light in future."

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

What is Nepali media writing about Balen Shah's visit to India?

Do expensive air purifiers really provide cleaner air? What to look for while buying

'Even the mehndi on my hands has not been removed and I am making rounds of the court'; What is the case of Shravani Rane and Mohammad Faiz?

must read

most popular