Photo by Andrii Gorb / Ukrinform/Future Publishing via Getty Images
A large-scale investigation by the National Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU), as a result of which General of the Security Service of Ukraine Sergei Duka was arrested, became the main news of the beginning of this month in Ukraine.
President Vladimir Zelensky states that he has instructed the acting the head of the SBU, Alexander Poklad, to prepare a systematic plan for strengthening the main Ukrainian intelligence service, and promises to give “answers to significant personnel issues” in the SBU. There are no details yet about what answers (and what questions) are being discussed, but Zelensky previously spoke about “frankly unpleasant, frankly shameful, absolutely unacceptable things” in which the special service was allegedly involved.
The head of NABU, Semyon Krivonos, warns: his agency is now in the most dangerous situation since the existence of the anti-corruption bureau, and many financial and industrial clans and political forces have joined forces to neutralize the main asset of NABU - the trust of Ukrainian society. These efforts are being coordinated from a single center, Krivonos said at a meeting with reporters on November 20, promising to release additional information on this matter later. Anti-corruption authorities have indeed recently faced waves of criticism against them - they are accused of being politicized and even trying to disrupt peace negotiations in Ukraine.
In a word, the echoes of “Carthage-2” continue to shake the Ukrainian information space. In the development of this case, there are dozens of people in camouflage and balaclavas in the center of Kyiv, the head of a drug cartel, answering questions about love, calls to a fortune teller and “thieves' runs.”
The BBC has collected the main points in the development of numerous storylines in perhaps the most resonant criminal case currently being investigated in Ukraine.
And if you want to remember what we are talking about in the Carthage-2 case, read our previous text on this topic:
Duca is released from pre-trial detention center
What happened earlier in this storyline: on November 6, the court arrested SBU Major General Sergei Duka, who is suspected of participating in a criminal organization, for two months, setting his bail at 65 million hryvnia (almost one and a half million dollars).
In court, Duca said that he and his family did not have that kind of money. Acting The head of the SBU, Alexander Poklad, announced that he had fired two high-ranking intelligence officers involved in the Carthage-2 scandal - apparently one of them was Sergei Duka.
End of Most Popular
Photo by Oleksandr Magula/Suspilne Ukraine/JSC "UA:PBC"/Global Images Ukraine via Getty Images
This extension will help if you have difficulties accessing the BBC Russian Service website.
Download extension
End of story Chrome browser extension - link
What happened next: Immediately after Duka was placed under arrest, the Ukrayinska Pravda publication, citing sources in law enforcement agencies, reported that ordinary employees of the regional branches of the SBU were required to transfer money for bail to the general. “Operative officers must transfer 50 thousand hryvnia, heads of sectors and departments and their deputies - 150 thousand each,” the publication said.
Duka's defense attorney, Yuriy Sukhov, did not deny that a significant portion of the payments (according to Ukrainian law, the deposit does not have to be paid in one transaction) comes from the general's colleagues, but he categorically denied that these transfers were made under duress.
As a result, on November 13, Duca was given the full amount of bail - the court later reported that a total of 1,636 transactions were received into his account - and he was released from custody in the evening of the same day.
Duka's release made a strong impression. At the exit from the Kyiv pre-trial detention center, he was greeted with applause by dozens of people in camouflage without identification marks and wearing masks on their faces. One of the people who greeted him handed Duque a pistol when he was released. Surrounded by these same people, the general held an impromptu briefing.
There, Duca stated that he was not involved in the crimes charged against him, and his prosecution was “revenge of the leaders of the anti-corruption agencies for the events of last year.” Then Duka was called the curator of a series of searches and detentions of NABU detectives, which took place on the eve of the adoption by the Rada of a scandalous law limiting the powers of anti-corruption bodies.
Duca added that the activities of NABU and SAPO weaken the position of the Ukrainian delegation at the peace negotiations.
Photo by Pavlo Bahmut/ Ukrinform/Future Publishing via Getty Images
“Open your eyes and see what is happening in the state. At a time when the state leadership is flying into extremely difficult negotiations, employees of anti-corruption bodies are carrying out so-called super-implementations, which do not end in anything, which undermine our negotiating position and force us to make concessions to our territorial integrity and sovereignty,” he said.
Duka left the pre-trial detention center accompanied by people who did not reveal their faces.
Commentators discussed both the ethics of collecting funds among intelligence officers to bail their colleague suspected of serious crimes - and the validity of these suspicions was confirmed at least by the dismissal of Duca from his position - and the appearance in the city center of dozens of strong young men, probably intelligence officers, without any military orders.
“There is a president and [acting head of the SBU] Poklad, who fires someone, and there is a person who [...] formed his own army of 1,600 people who paid bail for him [...], who does not care about the reputation of the president, and Poklad, and the Service [...] It is, in principle, such a small Prigozhin formed in Ukraine with his own army,” former Deputy Prosecutor General of Ukraine Viktor Chumak said on Radio NV.
"Mexican" gives "interview"
What happened in this storyline before: Russian citizen Yegor Burkin (previously he used a Ukrainian passport in the name of Yegor Levchenko and other documents issued by other countries), listed in the NABU records under the nickname “Mexican”, according to the prosecution, is the leader of a criminal organization exposed by anti-corruption officials. According to NABU, he is abroad.
What happened next: A few days after the NABU published the materials of the Carthage-2 case, a number of well-known Ukrainian journalists and bloggers received an offer from an anonymous addressee to record an interview with Yegor Burkin, the “Mexican.” Some of them ignored the proposal, others put forward their demands for the format of such communication in response.
However, already on November 13, a 2.5-hour recording of a conversation allegedly with the same “Mexican” appeared on the YouTube channel of blogger Vasily Timoshenko, who describes himself as a producer of millionaire bloggers and a consultant for the development of personal branding.
All this time, Tymoshenko communicates with his interlocutor in audio mode - he explained this with fears for his safety. The participants in the conversation did not provide any evidence that the voice - however, very reminiscent of the one heard on the NABU tapes - really belongs to Burkin. The legality of using the contents of this conversation has become the subject of heated debate among Ukrainian journalists - there is still no “reinforced” confidence that it was Burkin who communicated with Tymoshenko.
However, we can state that someone (perhaps the “Mexican” himself) - in addition to answering questions like “What is love for you?” and “What would you recommend young people do now?” — voiced on behalf of Yegor Burkin a number of theses regarding the Carthage-2 case.
Photo copyright: NABU
Firstly, the alleged “Mexican” called the Khimprom drug cartel “a fairy tale made up by journalists”, and described his relationship with illegal activities as “I’m not a saint in many ways, I’m not trying to pretend to be white, clean and fluffy, but I clearly operate on the edge of the law.”
Secondly, Tymoshenko’s interlocutor stated that the conversations published by NABU allegedly with his participation are authentic. He confirmed that for years he had been paying bribes to the highest ranks of the law enforcement system of Ukraine for “protection protection” for the call centers he owned - while naming the names of the alleged bribe-takers (including Sergei Duka) and the amounts transferred to them. At first, the alleged “Mexican” stated, communication took place directly with these law enforcement officers, then, fearing to be documented, they transferred communication to “Criminal” - Andrei Osipov.
Thirdly, Tymoshenko’s interlocutor denied his involvement in the drug business, saying that the U420 chain of stores he owned allegedly sold “legal drugs” - substances legally produced in legal factories in Poland and the Czech Republic.
Fourthly, the alleged “Mexican” denies the intention to beat or pour acid on journalist Denis Bigus, whose publication was investigating the work of the U420 store chain, and calls his words on this matter on NABU records a “bluff” - in order to create an image of a cruel and uncompromising person. As evidence of his assertion, Tymoshenko’s interlocutor cites the fact that in the end nothing bad happened to Bigus.
Fifthly, the alleged “Mexican” several times during the interview called the law enforcement system of Ukraine riddled with corruption and threatened law enforcement officers, who, according to him, are now allowing themselves “outright lawlessness,” with responsibility after the change of power. At the same time, Tymoshenko’s interlocutor declares his readiness to cooperate with Ukrainian anti-corruption authorities, as well as American law enforcement officers: “I am ready to cooperate and tell the truth [...] Condition, no problem, let’s negotiate.”
The video, published by Vasily Tymoshenko, has received more than 1.8 million views, but the range of attitudes towards it in Ukraine remains incredibly wide - some consider it almost the “revelations of a modern Robin Hood”, others consider it an ingenuous operation of the Russian special services, with which, according to NABU records, the real Burkin collaborated.
Anti-corruption authorities call Yegor Burkin the leader of a criminal organization, but to date they have not brought a single suspicion against him in the Carthage-2 case. The head of the SAPO Alexander Klimenko says that there is no intrigue in this: a suspicion is being prepared, investigators are simply trying to establish the last address of residence of the “Mexican” through requests to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and other departments - without this data it is impossible to formally issue a suspicion to him.
End of Subscribe to our social networks and newsletters
The fugitive prosecutor general strikes back
Photo by Marianna Kotyk/ Ukrinform/Future Publishing via Getty Images
What happened earlier in this storyline: The then current Prosecutor General of Ukraine, Ruslan Kravchenko, left the territory of Ukraine on the night of September 14 amid a scandal caused by the publication of the first part of the materials of the Carthage case about the “protection protection” of fraudulent call centers by the highest ranks of the prosecutor’s office. Before fleeing, Kravchenko announced the opening of criminal cases against the head of NABU Semyon Krivonos and a “close person” of the head of the SAPO Alexander Klimenko.
The very next day, the Rada dismissed Kravchenko, and the Prosecutor General’s Office closed the cases opened by him. The Ukrainian BBC service wrote about the details of the cases against Semyon Krivonos. In response to requests from journalists to comment on their plot, the head of NABU answered only, “This is nonsense.” Since then, there have been no new comments from Krivonos on this matter.
What happened next: on November 16 and 17, Ruslan Kravchenko published two videos containing, apparently, recordings of conversations and telephone conversations wiretapped as part of a criminal case, in which, according to the ex-prosecutor general, the wife of the head of the SAPO, a lawyer at one of the Kyiv law firms, Alexander Klimenko, was involved.
Kravchenko claims that the real purpose for which the anti-corruption authorities conducted searches in the Office of the Prosecutor General in early September was not to search for evidence of the involvement of senior ranks of the Prosecutor General’s Office in the “protection protection” of call centers, but to seize the materials of this particular criminal case, in which Alexandra Klimenko appears. The head of the SAPO rejects this claim.
In any case, Kravchenko did not say where he got the records he published or what their procedural status was.
Photo by Yevhen Kotenko/ Ukrinform/Future Publishing via Getty Images
His first video allegedly records negotiations between Klimenko, her friend and the head of the company where she works, Natalia Redich, and a fortune teller named Veronica. Conversations between them take place shortly after anti-corruption authorities conducted searches at the Prosecutor General's Office. Klimenko asks Redich for an urgent meeting, informs her about a certain criminal case and that her husband, the head of the SAPO, “is yelling at her, freaking out, because she (talks a lot).” At the same time, the friends take turns asking their friend the fortune teller Veronica for advice about what is happening. In one of the wiretaps, Redich asks Veronica whether “they are listening to her phone.” “No, you have security at home,” she replies.
The second video, posted by Kravchenko, reveals the details of the case, which the characters in the first video are probably worried about.
It concerns the defense of the mayor of the city of Sambir, Lviv region, by the law firm where Klymenko works, who was accused by NABU and SAP of illegal enrichment. The firm takes on this case, despite the conflict of interest - to avoid claims on this matter, they formally assign a lawyer not associated with the firm to it. The subjects of the wiretaps—lawyers and the mayor’s confidant, sometimes in the presence of Klimenko’s wife—discuss possible methods of influencing prosecutors and judges.
“I propose to the head of the SAPO to resign now, so as not to tarnish the honor of the institution and not hide behind the team. Because to be continued,” Ruslan Kravchenko wrote in a telegram.
The head of the SAPO is not going to follow the proposal of the ex-prosecutor general. At a meeting with journalists on November 20, he said that there was no evidence of his wife’s involvement in any illegal activities - moreover, she had nothing to do with the case of the mayor of Sambir. “I have not discussed this matter with anyone, including my wife. My wife no longer works at this law office. I have not communicated with Redich and do not communicate at all,” he explained.
And in general, Klimenko added, there is a court decision in this case: the mayor of Sambir lost it, that is, the lawyers he turned to did not help him. Journalist Danilo Mokrik, having analyzed the content of Kravchenko’s tapes, published a fragment of the decision that confirms the words of the head of the SAP.
Duca answers questions
What happened in this storyline before: Even upon leaving the pre-trial detention center, Duca called for the creation of an investigative commission in parliament that would take a closer look at the activities of anti-corruption bodies and their leaders.
This statement was used by opposition deputy Alexey Goncharenko, who heads one of the investigative commissions already working in the Rada of the current convocation: he invited Duca to speak at its meeting on November 18, and he responded to this proposal with consent.
What happened next: Sergei Duka’s communication with Goncharenko’s investigative commission (mainly with its head himself) lasted more than three hours.
Duca came to the commission meeting in military uniform, with general's shoulder straps: according to him, he was “only” removed from his position, but not fired from the ranks of the SBU.
Regarding the case in which the general received suspicion, Duca once again stated his non-involvement in any illegal activities.
At the same time, he confirmed that five or six years ago he was introduced to Andrei “Criminal” Osipov by the then first deputy head of the SBU Vasily Malyuk: “Introduced him as a person who could help in the interests of the Service [...] He was not an agent, he was a person who could one-time help in some matters.”
“To detain a drug manufacturer, you need another drug manufacturer, to detain a thief, you need another thief. It’s only in a film that you can walk down the street, film some traffic and solve a high-profile murder, a contract killing, or a high-profile theft. This doesn’t happen in life,” Duca concluded.
Osipov, the SBU general added, not only regularly shared information with him about the news of the criminal environment, but, according to Duka, at least several times served well the national security of Ukraine. For example, in 2022, Duka said, a group of thieves in law, oriented towards the FSB, under the leadership of Shakro Molodoy, tried to organize riots in all prisons of Ukraine and issued a corresponding “thieves’ run.” “Then it was stopped through Andrei’s efforts,” Duca said.
At the same time, the general added, he never addressed Osipov as “brother,” which is the type of address most often found in the correspondence released by NABU. “What kind of brother is he to me,” Duka was indignant in response to this question.
And in general, he said, the correspondence allegedly with his participation was falsified: “I claim that they substituted what was convenient for them for me.”
Duka said that he did not know Yegor Burkin and had never communicated with him by phone, but his SBU unit was preparing materials for Ukraine to impose sanctions against him and other members of the “top” of Khimprom. And in general, Duca added, there is operational information that at the end of last year one of the NABU employees, “whose status is unknown,” went to a meeting with “Mexican.”
Duca said that there is no conflict between the SBU and NABU: everyone is doing their job. On this, by the way, the head of the SAPO Alexander Klimenko agrees with him in absentia: at a meeting with journalists on November 20, he said that the claims of the anti-corruption bodies do not concern the entire SBU and not the entire prosecutor’s office: “We are talking about several divisions and some managers.”
Another question is how to interpret a series of searches and detentions of NABU detectives, which SBU officers carried out last summer just before the parliament adopted a scandalous law limiting the powers of the bureau. NABU and SAPO are convinced that these events are interconnected. General Duca claims that there is no connection between them: they say, where am I, and where is some kind of bill.
According to him, the SBU and, in particular, the unit he commanded, conducted a number of criminal cases against NABU detectives and the head of the bureau, but at the end of last year he was personally instructed to put them on pause by the then head of the SBU Vasily Malyuk. Duca clarified that this happened after Malyuk’s visit to the President’s Office.
“Anti-corruption bodies have become a lever of influence on the top leadership of the state,” Duca concluded.
“(The work of anti-corruption bodies) weakens the position of the negotiating group. Putin tells jokes about NABU - I think it’s a madhouse. The actions of NABU only benefit Putin. I think this organization acts against the interests of the state,” he added.
These accusations were later responded to by the head of the SAPO, Alexander Klimenko. “The narrative (of our detractors) has changed over time. At first they talked about the Russian trace in NABU, which turned out to be nothing. Then they began to spread the message that there was no need to investigate corruption during the war. Now they are trying to impose a narrative that NABU and SAPO investigations into top corruption are undermining peace negotiations. Each of these narratives is artificially invented and has nothing to do with reality,” he said at a meeting with journalists.
After the end of the meeting of the investigative commission, its head, somewhat stunned, Alexey Goncharenko, said that he would transfer the video recording and transcript of the conversation with Duca to law enforcement agencies, and added that he would invite the former head of the SBU Vasily Malyuk, the heads of NABU and SAPS Semyon Krivonos and Alexander Klymenko, as well as ex-Prosecutor General Ruslan Kravchenko to the next meeting of the commission, scheduled for next Monday, November 23. Goncharenko added that due to the current circumstances, Kravchenko will be able to speak before the commission via video link.
With the participation of Maryana Matveychuk.
Download the new BBC World Service app!
When you first open the app, select "BBC News Russian Service" and receive notifications about important news, analysis, videos and podcasts.
Important: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
Find out more
Video playlist
End Video playlist




