Image source: Getty Images
Job in Indian Army does not mean just employment. For many generations, it has been a secure future, regular earnings, pension after retirement and also the honor of serving the country for the youth.
But in the year 2022, the central government made a major change in this system. Government started Agneepath scheme. Under this, the youth joining the army were given the opportunity to serve only for four years.
Only 25 percent of these youth were to be kept in the army permanently. The remaining 75 percent youth were to be out of service after four years. He was to get a lump sum amount, but was not to get pension and other benefits received in the army.
Now the first batch recruited under this scheme is about to complete four years.
Meanwhile, the government has decided to give them a chance to serve in the army for some more time.
This decision is being considered an important change in the Agneepath scheme. There has been debate regarding this scheme since the beginning.
"Firefighters will get more salary than before"
On 4 November, Chief of Defense Staff General NS Raja Subramani announced that the youth recruited under the Agneepath scheme, who would not be able to get a place in the permanent services, would be given a chance to serve for two more years. During this period they will get more salary than before.
After this they will be given another chance to join the regular army. However, for this they will have to fulfill the prescribed selection process and conditions.
End
General Subramani said that this decision has been taken on the basis of suggestions received from the army. He made it clear that the Agneepath scheme will continue.
The timing of this decision is also very important. The initial four-year tenure of more than 18 thousand 300 Agniveers of the first batch is going to be completed by the end of 2026. According to officials, more than 3 lakh firefighters working in the Army, Navy and Air Force can benefit from this new system.
However, it is not clear whether the future recruited batches will also get the benefit of this change or not. BBC has contacted the Defense Ministry for information in this regard.
The Defense Ministry has defended the Agneepath plan. The ministry says that in the internal assessment, Agniveer has been found to be physically fit, enthusiastic towards work and capable of adopting new technology. According to the ministry, through this scheme, youth from different districts have got an opportunity to join the army. Also, the recruitment process has been made more uniform and systematic than before.
Why was there controversy over Agneepath scheme?
Image source: AFP via Getty Images
Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava
Learn more
When the government started the Agneepath scheme, many reasons were given behind it. The government said that this scheme will reduce the average age of soldiers in the army. This will also reduce long-term expenses on salaries and pensions. Also, the army will get young and capable soldiers to work with new technology.
But military experts and opposition leaders raised questions on this plan. He said that a four-year job cannot be an alternative to the traditional and permanent job available in the army.
Retired Major General Yash Mor, a critic of the plan, says army jobs were a way for many youth to make a better life.
He said, "Becoming a soldier in the army was an opportunity for these youth to change their lives. Through this job, they could take their families out of poverty or low-income life."
The Agneepath scheme was brought at a time when the army recruitment process was halted for almost two years during the Corona epidemic. Because of this, thousands of youth were waiting for the recruitment to start. Many youth had prepared for years to join the army.
In such a situation, after the announcement of the new scheme, massive protests took place across the country. The youth said that the entire system of the job for which they had worked hard for years has been changed.
Its biggest impact was seen in those states and cities where joining the army has been a major source of employment for a long time. In many families, youth have been joining the army for generations.
Kulbir Singh Chaudhary, who runs an institute for recruitment preparation in Dehradun, says that after the introduction of Agneepath scheme, the interest of the youth in joining the army had reduced considerably. He had also stopped running training batches for fire fighters.
However, he hopes that the new decision of the government will increase the confidence of the youth again.
He says, "The possibility of serving in the army for a longer period and later joining permanently can give some confidence to the youth."
Shortage of soldiers in the army is also a big reason
Image source: Bloomberg via Getty Images
This decision of the government has come at a time when there is a shortage of soldiers in the Indian Army. In November last year, an Indian Express report said that there was a shortage of about 1.80 lakh soldiers in the Army alone. According to the report, the army was also considering increasing recruitment.
However, the controversy over the Agneepath scheme is not limited to the future of the soldiers after four years. Experts who question this plan also ask whether a youth can be made an experienced soldier in just four years.
Former Additional Director General of Border Security Force, Sanjeev Krishna Sood has also expressed concern about the short period of service. He says that this system can be more difficult for the soldiers engaged in technical work. Such work requires special training and experience.
Retired Major General Yash Mor believes that the strength of the army is determined not only by weapons, but also by the experience of the soldiers and the trust built among them.
He said, "It takes eight to nine years to turn a newly recruited soldier into a reliable and experienced soldier. And such a soldier can handle the responsibility of a tank driving team, an artillery team or a small contingent."
He further said, "During these years, army traditions, mutual coordination, brotherhood and fighting spirit develop in the soldiers. These qualities cannot be developed overnight."
At the same time, Sanjeev Krishna Sood believes that by getting additional time of two years, the skills of fire fighters can improve. Especially they will get more experience in operating modern and special equipment.
Some senior army officers have also welcomed this decision of the government. Air Vice Marshal Shekhar Yadav told news agency ANI that this decision will give the army an opportunity to retain trained soldiers for a longer period.
Challenges may increase within the army
Image source: NurPhoto via Getty Images
However, this change may also create some new challenges within the army units.
Regular soldiers, Agniveer with four years of service and Agniveer who have got additional tenure of two years can work together in the same unit. But the salary, promotion and benefits received after termination of job will be different for all of them.
Experts fear that this may affect mutual coordination and unity among the soldiers.
Apart from this, a big question is whether this change will achieve the objective of reducing the government's expenditure.
Nearly half of India's defense budget is spent on salaries and pensions. Because of this, less money is left for purchasing modern weapons and military equipment.
Through the Agneepath scheme, the government wanted to limit the number of soldiers receiving pension and other benefits for a long time. This was expected to reduce the burden on the defense budget.
But critics of the plan say the military's capability and operational power should not be compromised to save money.
Yash Mor says, "We are not against change. But there can be other ways to bring about change."
His suggestion is that the government can reduce the number of recruitments every year, but can keep the soldiers in the army for a longer period.
He also mentioned India's borders with Pakistan and China. Soldiers are deployed in these areas throughout the year. In such a situation, the army needs adequate number of soldiers along with their experience.
Retired Major General Birendra Singh Dhanoa has also raised questions on the economic usefulness of this scheme. He says that the army trains soldiers to operate modern and expensive equipment. In such a situation, how right is it to remove him from service after just four years?
He raised the question, "A lot of time and money is spent in training on modern equipment. In such a situation, is it not necessary to get full benefit of the expenditure made on training?"
According to retired Major General Dhanoa, when the government announced the Agneepath scheme, many retired military officers had given another suggestion.
He said, "We had suggested that if the government wants to reduce the financial burden, it can change the conditions and duration of service. The youth should be kept in the army for eight to nine years and after that more of them should be included in permanent service."
Question on government's decision before elections
This change in the Agneepath scheme is also considered politically important. Elections are to be held soon in Punjab, Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand. A large number of youth from these three states have been joining the army. Army jobs are also an important source of employment here.
Congress has called this decision of the government a U-turn. The party alleges that the government is making changes in the Agneepath scheme due to fear of loss of votes in the elections.
At the same time, this decision has brought some relief for the firefighters who are about to complete four years of service. Now they can get a chance to work for two more years, gain more experience and get better salary. After this they will also have another chance to join the regular army.
But despite this, there is no complete confidence about his future. Two years of additional service means they will have to wait longer to decide their career.
It is not yet clear how many firefighters will be able to get permanent jobs after the completion of additional two years. In such a situation, the biggest question before many youth is whether they will finally get a chance to make a permanent career in the army or they will have to look for a new job again.
Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.
Download the new BBC World Service app
Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place
Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
short video
end of short video




