image copyrightGetty Images
Hours after launching his full-scale invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022, Vladimir Putin gathered Russia's richest men in the Kremlin's cavernous Yekaterininsky Hall.
More than thirty people gathered next to a wall, wearing masks due to the Covid pandemic. A Russian journalist described them as "pale and tired-looking."
Upon entering, Putin sat on the other side of the room, creating a great distance between him and the businessmen. As usual, he was not wearing a mask.
Using his usually cryptic language, he said he hoped they would support the war.
"I would like to ask you to show understanding of what is happening," he said, "and to work together with the government to find the tools that support production, the economy and employment."
In the video of the meeting published by the Kremlin, none of the invited billionaires spoke a word.
That silence has become a characteristic of the Russian super-rich.
During Putin's decades of rule, they learned that the price of speaking out could be very high.
End of Most read
In 2003, oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Russia's richest man at the time, who bankrolled several opposition groups, accused Putin of presiding over rampant corruption.
He spent the next ten years in prison, convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement, a warning to other potential critics. He denied the charges.
image copyrightALEXEY NIKOLSKY/SPUTNIK/AFP via Getty Images
And even if some of the magnates opposed the war, they tended to keep their opinions to themselves.
But even in that silence, there are murmurs: some members of Russia's once-powerful business elite seem to imagine a Russia without Putin.
They wonder whether, once the president leaves office or dies, the country could look more like it did in the 1990s — when oligarchs enjoyed the fruits of power — or even whether healthier politics could take hold.
Journalist Arkady Ostrovsky, a prominent Kremlin watcher at The Economist newspaper who recently spent hours interviewing one of Russia's richest men, feels a "historic political shift" is underway in how the ultra-rich see the country's future.
Restless tycoons
All the news you need is on BBC World Service
Download it here
End of Ad app
The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 gave rise to a powerful new force in the domestic political landscape: people who took advantage of the end of communism and became extraordinarily rich, and who then wanted to control politicians for their own benefit.
They were called "oligarchs", a term that in ancient Greek means "the few who rule." They had money, which back then meant power.
This time of the turbulent nineties was when the so-called "new Russians" burst onto the scene. Large state-owned companies became available to anyone, and men with the right connections became millionaires—even billionaires—almost overnight.
Corruption was widespread, cronyism was rampant and contract killings were frequent.
But almost immediately after being elected president for the first time in 2000, Putin subdued the oligarchs.
He had little interest in sharing power with anyone else. He could afford to take on the billionaires because the Russian economy was recovering and the central government was getting stronger.
image copyrightNurPhoto/NurPhoto via Getty Images
Bill Browder, a financier who was the largest foreign investor in Russia and was banned from entering the country in 2005 after campaigning against corruption, claims that Russian tycoons cowed and kowtowed to Putin, for example at the Davos economic forum in the years before the war, when they were still welcome there.
"I remember seeing oligarchs walking around like they owned the place, arrogant, self-assured individuals. And then Putin appeared, and it was amazing to see how these individuals, supposedly alpha males on steroids, became submissive, almost desperate children," he told the BBC.
Since the outbreak of war in 2022, the Kremlin has kept Russia's richest businessmen in line with a relentless policy of rewards and punishments.
Critics of the war have had their assets confiscated, while loyalists have been rewarded with lucrative government contracts for the war: there are more Russian billionaires today than ever before (155 in total, according to Forbes magazine). Their collective wealth has reached a new high of nearly $700 billion.
But even for those tycoons who have remained loyal and been rewarded, all that money doesn't seem to make them happy. Some are starting to get impatient.
Autocracy, oligarchy or democracy?
Their billions don't go as far as they used to: At the national level, they can't buy much political influence.
"They have no cards in this game," says exiled politician and analyst Dmitry Nekrasov. "They are rich because they have some relationship with Putin, not the other way around."
And outside Russia they are marginalized due to Western sanctions imposed on Russia following its large-scale invasion.
"They are treated like petty criminals. They cannot fly on their private planes. Their yachts cannot dock in the best ports in Europe. It must be terrible and humiliating for them," says Browder, Putin's outspoken critic.
So, quietly, some are beginning to wonder what will happen when Putin leaves the political scene. That's what well-informed analysts, immersed in the world of these magnates, tell me.
There is no immediate prospect of the president's departure, nor reason to think that his health is delicate.
However, Putin, who turned 74 last month, has served in the Kremlin for a quarter of a century; in Moscow they know that their exit will come one day.
When asked by Reuters last year whether he intended to remain in office until 2036, when his constitutional mandate ends, Putin replied: "Only God knows whether we will be healthy enough."
Image source, CARL DE SOUZA/AFP via Getty Images
If Putin were to resign or die in office, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin would take over. However, Mishustin has not shown presidential ambitions (which is probably why he was appointed). This would create a power vacuum.
If this happens, Russia experts I have spoken to foresee several possible scenarios.
Some in the West, and no doubt in Russia too, hope that democracy will flourish in a post-Putin Russia, with a government led by the people, rather than by a new clique of oligarchs or a single autocrat.
However, according to analysts, this seems to be the least likely path. Major democratic institutions have been weakened or destroyed under Putin.
"Russia is so accustomed to violence that it has become unaccustomed to conventional democratic procedures," says Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian journalist and analyst.
Another way is greater autocracy. A different figure could replace Putin and continue his culture of repression. But Prokopenko believes that it would not be another authoritarian dictatorship, at least not immediately.
These things take time, he says: at first, Putin's successor would be weaker than him and have fewer resources.
And then there is the third option: that the tycoons reassert their power and Russia returns to a system similar to that of the oligarchy of the 1990s.
From "boss" to "grandfather"
Dmitry Nekrasov, a former Kremlin adviser and opposition politician now living in exile, says that in this scenario, the country would be governed by a handful of powerful elite clans allied with business interests.
This last option, of course, is the one that many tycoons want. "They want to go back to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of their assets and when they understood the rules of the game," says Prokopenko, who has spent a lot of time talking to Russia's richest people.
Although their power has been seriously eroded since the 1990s, it is still worth listening to the tycoons: given their immense wealth, it seems likely that sooner or later they will try to reassert their political influence.
According to Nekrasov, the exiled politician, some are already trying to befriend the right security officials or ministers.
However, he says taking a step further is too dangerous.
image copyrightVladimir Smirnov SPUTNIK/KREMLIN POOL/EPA/Shutterstock
According to Nekrasov, the behavior of tycoons in the coming years will depend in part on their financial situation.
Those with abundant liquidity will have greater confidence to "play politics" and position themselves strategically, preparing for a post-Putin country. On the other hand, those whose wealth depends on state contracts or government favor will be too afraid of losing everything.
Prokopenko says there has already been a change in the way businessmen talk about Putin.
He was previously nicknamed "Nachalnik" (which translates as "chief"), "Perviy" ("first") or by his initials "VV", all nicknames that denoted a certain respect. They now call him "Ded," with what Prokopenko describes as "a disdain." "Ded" translates as "old man" or "grandfather," a much less reverent name.
According to her, some wealthy Russians long for a "return of politics to people's lives," with less repression, greater freedom of expression and healthier competition between parties and politicians.
But, he adds, at the moment they are too afraid of that happening due to the oppressive atmosphere in Russia.
Prokopenko interviewed a tycoon who sat on his phone throughout the conversation, because he believed it would make digital eavesdropping by the secret police more difficult. "It seemed to me like a fear typical of the Stalinist era. It is totally irrational," he says.
An explosive interview
An interesting clue about what tycoons might want from a post-Putin future came from Andrey Melnichenko, known as the world's fertilizer king and currently Russia's eighth-richest man.
Earlier this year, he surprised everyone by giving an interview to The Economist, a rarity for a wealthy Russian, especially for a publication from a country the Kremlin considers hostile. They also published an essay written by him.
At some points in the interview, Melnichenko repeated the Kremlin's arguments. He stated that Ukraine is a battleground between Russia and the West, and that, in his opinion, the West ignores Russia's security concerns and threatens its sovereignty.
But then things got more interesting. Melnichenko did not call for Putin's resignation, but - and this is a crucial point - he advocated a change that would end one-man rule in Russia. He stated that Russia needs to interact more with the world.
Prokopenko believes that the tycoon was trying to generate a public debate. It was a "call for rich people like him to start talking," he says.
The journalist who interviewed him, Arkady Ostrovsky, tells me that the two had "tense and heated discussions" in "hotels and cafes, where they drank coffee, a lot of coffee, and sometimes smoked."
He says the tycoon appeared to be "sincerely reflecting" on his responses, rather than resorting to political tactics.
Nothing is simple in Russia, and most observers believe that the interview probably had some kind of approval - implicit or explicit - from the Kremlin. We do not know why the authorities would have so enthusiastically authorized this unusual call for change; It is possible that they were trying to demonstrate that a certain degree of pluralism still exists in the country.
No tycoon came out to support him. Even so, the journalist believes that Melnichenko was not only speaking for himself, but also for his business colleagues.
image copyrightAndrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Some hope that after Putin leaves, the country will become an "oligarchic republic," as journalist Ostrovsky describes it, something similar to what it was in the 1990s, with business elites in charge.
Drawing on his years reporting on Russia, Ostrovsky says many of the country's billionaires currently feel a "sense of dead end, a product of what this war has done to Russia... [an] absence of a future."
But even if the tycoons are thinking ahead, it seems unlikely they will act soon.
Browder, Putin's critic, says that while many of them are dissatisfied, they are unlikely to plot against Putin while he is still alive. "They understand that if they did anything to challenge Putin, he would kill them. And Putin is a very paranoid little man."
Mike Calvey, an American financier who was a key investor in Russia, agrees. "What can they do other than go straight to jail and lose their property? It's easy for people in London to say, 'Why don't you all get up and go straight to jail?' "That's precisely what would happen."
The richest men in Russia used to have great influence at the highest levels of power. Once Putin leaves power, they will no doubt try to regain their former influence. The question is: will the remnants of the current regime allow it?
This article was originally written in English and we used an artificial intelligence tool to translate it. A BBC journalist reviewed the text before publication. Learn more about how we use AI.
Download the new BBC World Service app. Choose BBC News Mundo and receive news alerts, documentaries and analysis, all in one place. Important: The new app is not available in the United Kingdom or the United States.
You can also follow us on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, X and our WhatsApp channel.
And don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter here to receive a special selection of our best content every Friday.
Discover more
Video
End of Video




