image copyrightGetty Images

"This is the building I need to bomb. The Naza of that attack was four," says a man whose only silhouette can be seen.

"What is Naza?" a second man asks.

"Collateral damage. The number of civilians who will die from an attack."

This is a scene from the acclaimed documentary Naza, directed by Israeli filmmakers Rachel Szor and Yuval Abraham.

"Naza" is an Israeli military acronym that has become familiar to many since the documentary's release.

The film investigates civilian casualties resulting from ongoing Israeli military operations in Gaza through interviews with 24 anonymous Israeli military and intelligence officers, who explain how artificial intelligence is used to identify potential targets.

Throughout the documentary, Yuval Abraham interviews unidentified sources on Tel Aviv rooftops at night, as the city's illuminated skyline glows behind him.

image copyrightThe Guardian

At its premiere at the Venice International Film Festival, the documentary won the Special Jury Prize. Additionally, he received a record 25-minute standing ovation.

But the film has provoked a strong reaction in Israel.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu claimed it was part of a wave of global incitement against Jews and ordered intelligence services to identify the participants.

Chief of Staff Lieutenant General Eyal Zamir declared the documentary an attack on Israel, while Culture Minister Miki Zohar accused the directors of "betrayal of the state" and called for their citizenship to be revoked.

However, the filmmakers defend their work.

Approval to "kill 500 people"

Their 80-minute documentary, they say, "details the systems behind Israel's mass and calculated killing of Palestinian civilians in Gaza" during the war that followed the Hamas-led attacks of October 7, 2023.

One of those interviewed claims to be aware of a case in which an attack was authorized to kill 500 people for "a single human target", an accusation that the Israeli military called "completely false."

The film is the result of almost three years of investigative journalism carried out by its directors in collaboration with the British newspaper The Guardian and the Israeli-Palestinian media +972 Magazine.

While 24 Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers appear in the documentary, the directors claim to have interviewed more than 100 sources during their research.

"By speaking to these soldiers, we were able to get an inside look at the targeting systems, AI-based systems and protocols behind the mass killing in Gaza," Yuval Abraham told the BBC World Service's Newshour programme.

According to the Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Ministry, more than 73,000 Palestinians, including more than 20,000 children, have died in the territory.

Abraham stated that the documentary arose from a feeling of responsibility as Israeli citizens.

"This comes from our identity as Israelis, who have seen the Netanyahu government destroy the Gaza Strip, kill tens of thousands of civilians, and from the feeling that we have a responsibility to try to do something about it."

The Israeli government claims to have done everything it can to avoid civilian casualties in its fight against Hamas militants, who it says infiltrate places such as hospitals, schools and shelters. Hamas denies using Gaza's civilian population as human shields.

"Where's dad?"

The documentary reflects the positions of the Israeli government and army, which affirm that their operations are directed exclusively against militants and that measures are taken to minimize damage to the civilian population. However, the testimonies of the soldiers interviewed tell a different story.

"This is not a military surgical operation carried out with the intention of minimizing the risk to civilians," Abraham told the BBC.

The film focuses on artificial intelligence-based targeting systems that the filmmakers say are used to identify potential targets and estimate likely civilian casualties.

One of the systems featured in the documentary is called "Where's Dad?", and, according to the filmmakers, it alerts intelligence services when a target returns home. The system supposedly tracks family members, sometimes through children's cell phones.

Rachel Szor explained that the surveillance system would monitor conversations for phrases like "Where's Daddy?" or "When are you arriving?", which could indicate that the person the system was addressing had arrived home.

"In the film you hear about these figures from Naza. You hear that there was general authorization to bomb up to 20 civilians... It is an algorithm that calculates how many people are going to be bombed in each house," Abraham told the BBC.

"What really happened after October 7 was that these Naza mechanisms [...] normalized and enabled the killing of civilians rather than minimizing it."

Sharp contrast

Naza is a documentary about the Gaza war with few images from inside the Strip. Instead, it takes place primarily on the rooftops of Tel Aviv at night, with sleek apartment buildings and brightly lit windows framing scenes of everyday life.

Those images stand in stark contrast to the devastation in Gaza, just 70 km to the south, shown in the film's final moments.

Rachel Szor explained that they chose Tel Aviv because many of the soldiers and intelligence officers interviewed were from that city, home of the Israeli army headquarters.

"They come from the elite of Israeli society. Sometimes they consider themselves leftist," he said.

image copyrightAnadolu via Getty Images

But how did they get so many soldiers and officers to talk so openly about what the Israeli army—and themselves—had done in Gaza?

Abraham said building trust was one of the biggest challenges they faced.

"Many of them felt that they were participating in the wrong thing, that they were involved in unjustified crimes or killings," he said.

According to him, much of the Israeli media lacked thorough critical analysis, which made it easier to conduct the interviews.

"Some of the people we talked to said they felt like they'd never been asked those questions before," he said. "Once we asked them, they agreed to talk."

All sources featured in the documentary spoke on condition of anonymity. "They take a big risk by speaking out," Abraham said. "That's why they are required to maintain confidentiality."

Provoking public debate

Since the film's media premiere at the Venice Film Festival, its directors claim to have received numerous death threats and have been branded traitors by critics in Israel.

Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett called the documentary a "horrible smear against our sons and daughters," while former Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman described the directors as "enemies of Israel."

Image source, AFP via Getty Images

The Israeli military has also issued a wide-ranging response, accusing the documentary of presenting "a distorted, misleading and false picture of the IDF's target planning and attack processes." He stated that the narrative is based on "substantial factual errors arising from a misrepresented and manipulative representation of reality."

Abraham said the filmmakers contacted the Israeli military on more than 10 occasions over nearly three years to make all of the film's main claims and rejected accusations that their information was inaccurate.

He argued that the anger directed at the documentary reflected a broader reluctance within Israeli society to confront the army's actions in Gaza, and said the film had sparked a level of public debate not seen since the start of the war.

"What we have seen in much of the Israeli media is either complete ignorance or justification of these crimes," he said.

"When the mass killing of civilians is normalized, the result is a state of total denial. We hope that this film will contribute to breaking down these barriers of denial in Israeli society."

This article was originally written in English and we used an artificial intelligence tool to translate it. A BBC journalist reviewed the text before publication. Learn more about how we use AI.

Discover more

Video

End of Video

Top news

Xi receives Trump and Putin in Shenzhen, China's "city of dreams": this is what they won't see

"I saw dozens of corpses to recognize my 14-year-old brother after the earthquakes in Venezuela and I still don't know if he is buried or missing"

Part of Crimean bridge built by Putin's government collapses as Ukraine celebrates 'unprecedented' attack

Don't miss it

Most popular readings