In recent days, American President Donald Trump has increased religious controversies by first attacking Pope Leo XIV and then publishing an image representing him as Jesus Christ. Actions that could harm the presidential party during the midterm elections in November.

Published on: 04/14/2026 - 6:44 p.m. Modified on: 04/14/2026 - 8:10 p.m.

Donald Trump ended up erasing the image of discord. After a day of intense controversy, the American president removed, on Monday April 13, the message on Truth Social containing an image in which he was visibly represented in the appearance of Christ the savior, accompanied by a multitude of other symbols of North American Christian nationalism.

“Blasphemous” had judged part of the Maga camp, including certain speakers on the very loyalist ultraconservative channel Fox News.

“Not a big fan” of Leo XIV

An action all the more poorly received as this staging generated by artificial intelligence was posted just one day after a long tirade by the Republican billionaire against Pope Leo XIV. “I’m not a big fan of the pope,” Donald Trump declared on Truth Social, before explaining in particular that he found the first North American pontiff “too weak against crime.”

An attack which itself came after a declaration, on Saturday, by Leo

To display this YouTube content, it is necessary to authorize audience measurement and advertising cookies.

An extension in your browser appears to be blocking the loading of the video player. To be able to watch this content, you must disable or uninstall it.

Donald Trump apparently immediately felt targeted, even though Leo

It is certainly difficult not to see in the papal declarations a reaction to the conflict in the Middle East. There is, however, nothing surprising in this speech which is part of "a Vatican tradition of acting according to a moral sense" against wars in general, assures Blandine Chelini-Pont, specialist in the geopolitics of Christianity and the political history of American Catholicism at the University of Aix-Marseille.

But for Donald Trump, already battered in the polls because of an unpopular war, the papal opinion goes down badly. Especially since it comes from a North American pope. His words are more taken into account by public opinion in the United States and more difficult to question than those, for example, of his predecessor François, originally from Argentina, "who could be described [by the Trumpist camp, Editor's note] as a leftist coming from the southern hemisphere", underlines Blandine Chelini-Pont.

The long diatribe of the American president who accuses Leo

For her, Donald Trump is trying to initiate with Leo XIV the kind of verbal standoff that he is used to with his political adversaries in the United States or elsewhere. But, in this case, "he simply insults a part of North American Christians and millions of faithful Catholics around the world", estimates Emma Long.

A very messianic pose

The pope, for his part, was careful not to enter into controversy. “I am not a politician, I do not intend to enter into a debate with him,” he reacted while traveling in Algeria.

Instead of calming the spirits, Donald Trump then plunged into religious escalation with his controversial image overflowing with Christian symbols. The president appears in the center of the image in a very messianic pose with a light - which we imagine is of divine origin - radiating from the hands. “It is a direct reference to the icon of divine mercy,” priest Paul Adrien, very present on social networks, explains to La Croix.

Also readOffice of Faith, Christian nationalism at the Pentagon: Is Donald Trump on a crusade?

And it is not just any Christ representation that is used here. “The colors of the stole, that is to say the liturgical garment he wears, do not correspond to Protestant imagery but much more to Catholic codes,” analyzes Blandine Chelini-Pont.

As such, this visual can be seen as a new attempt by Donald Trump to measure himself against Leo XIV. Could the American president have believed that he would make a good impression on American Catholics by transforming himself into an even more incontestable authority in their eyes than the pope?

Not impossible. Indeed, “some American fundamentalists have compared Donald Trump to the Chosen One,” notes Blandine Chelini-Pont. Starting with Paula White-Cain, the president's personal spiritual advisor, who drew a parallel between the life of the American billionaire and that of Christ. For the expert, it is therefore possible that Donald Trump “thought he could legitimately represent himself as Jesus Christ in an image”.

This is also not the first time that Internet memes have integrated Donald Trump into very religious iconography. After the attack from which he escaped in July 2024, images showed Christ as the guardian angel of the man who was then still only a candidate for the presidency.

But this time, it doesn't work. The Newsweek site even compiled a list of all the influential members of the Maga camp who criticized this image.

A less welded Maga base

By improvising himself as a modern-day Jesus Christ, Donald Trump has “touched the ultimate symbol” of Christianity and pushed the envelope too far, according to experts interviewed by France 24.

The blowback is also a sign of politically stormier times for Donald Trump. Just a few months ago, Donald Trump's hold on his camp was such that no one would have dared to criticize this image. Not anymore. The controversial handling of the Epstein case, as well as the contested right-wing decision of his war-mongering foreign policy, have left scars. “As long as Donald Trump applied the policies desired by these right-wing religious circles, this electorate turned a blind eye to his escapades, but now, it seems that this is becoming less obvious,” analyzes Emma Long.

It remains to be seen whether the attacks on the Pope and the faux pas of the image posted by Donald Trump can cost him dearly politically. “Part of the religious electorate, notably Christian nationalists, will not be affected,” assures Emma Long. The image, which mixed Christian symbols with nationalist references such as the American eagle, the flag and the soldiers, was even tailor-made for them, believes this specialist.

Read alsoAmerican presidential election: the nebula of Christian nationalists in the service of Donald Trump

The judgment of Catholics should be harsher. These controversies “risk doing the president an electoral disservice to this electorate,” says Blandine Chelini-Pont. Indeed, if most evangelical (Protestant) Christians form the base of the Maga camp, Catholics have less strong loyalty. It is possible that these controversies and "the positions taken by authorities like the Pope or North American cardinals, who in January criticized the behavior of ICE [the immigration police, Editor's note]" will alienate some Catholics from the Republicans.

These faithful will certainly closely follow the reactions of the first of them within the Trump administration: J. D. Vance. “It will be very interesting to see how the vice-president reacts to all this,” notes Blandine Chelini-Pont.

For the moment, the man who will soon publish a book on his late conversion to Catholicism "has been very diplomatic in seeking to clear the ground", analyzes Emma Long. In any case, much more than when he criticizes European countries. He notably declared that it was normal that there could be disagreements between the pope and the American president.

For Emma Long, the impact of this political sequence on the Catholic vote will depend on the ability of the Trump-Vance duo to minimize its importance while moving on. Because otherwise, according to her, “this electorate will remember it in November”.

Keywords associated with the article

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.