Rocky premiered on 20 November 1976 in New York, and was released in the UK two months later. Read Derek Malcolm’s review
21 April 1977
Everyone knows that the script of Rocky (Leicester Sq Theatre, A) was hawked around studio after studio before Sylvester Stallone, its writer, who insisted on starring in his own picture, finally got his way. One shouldn’t be too surprised. It’s the story of half the most successful movies ever made. What adds gilt to this particular slice of gingerbread is that the fiction in this case isn’t much stranger than the truth.
All this should be a useful corrective to the view that Rocky is just skilfully manufactured romantic flim-flam, a grimy urban Love Story that was bound to give the film industry its biggest bonanza since Jaws and Cuckoo’s Nest. True, it manipulates its audience from start to finish giving off the indelible feeling that we are being played for suckers even while enjoying the experience.
But Rocky has its solid values too. It is better than Roots, saying more in less time; it is skilfully directed by John Avildsen (who did, after all give us Joe and Save the Tiger); and it contains a performance from Stallone which, like it or not, it is impossible not to watch. Even the bit players make their mark. The thing is all of a piece and thoroughly at ease within its own limitations.
Rocky, in case you don’t already know, is a small-time boxer, low even on the Philadelphia rating list, who makes a bit more dough on the side working for a neighbourhood loan shark. He’s a gentle giant who doesn’t actually break any backsliders’ thumbs and says to his fish back at his dingy flat: “If you guys could sing or dance, I wouldn’t be doing this.” And he doesn’t like being called “meat-bag” or “Goddam ape” by anyone but himself.
He’s a shambles and he knows it – the guy you instinctively want something nice to happen to. But soon your hopes glimmer. First he finds a girl (Talia Shire) who has a brain rather than a body like he had a body rather than a brain. The perfect soulmate, one at those few movie Plain Janes who doesn’t suddenly look a million dollars the moment she takes off her specs. Well, not directly anyway. Then the world heavyweight, due to fight in town, gets let down by his opponent. What about giving a local bum of the month a chance?
So it’s the black champion (Carl Weathers, doing a passable Ali) versus the Italian Stallion. “I like it,” says the money-man. “It’s very American.” Now Rocky gets the jitters. He’s only a ham-and-egger after all. But his girl stays firm: “Beethoven was deaf, Keller was blind,” she says. “You’ve got a good chance.” After a gruelling encounter, in which Rocky justifies himself by standing up for 15 rounds, the story ends. Now looking decidedly sexy, his girl hugs him in the ring.
The foregoing takes no account of the good performances contributed by Burt Young as the girl’s brother trying to get an incipient spinster off his hands and by Burgess Meredith as the old trainer who, having chucked Rocky out of his gym, offers to manage him when the championship chance comes though. And these are cameos that couldn’t have been effective if Stallone, the writer, and Avildsen, the director, hadn’t been on the ball with some very observant detail.
Stallone himself as Rocky, is unquestionably a discovery, the sort or presence the screen needs before attempting to make a former bit player into a star. The film is basically pap, a throwback to the dream factory of yesteryear. But we all know how beguiling that can be. They say it’s because we are fed up with nightmares, and that could be. I’d prefer to think, however, that Rocky is a success because of what it is rather than what it isn’t. It should at least get credit for that.




