image copyrightGetty Images

You may have had this experience: You and two friends are in regular contact and have met each other, but the chances of the three of you sitting at the same dinner table are few and far between.

Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are in a somewhat similar and delicate state.

The last time they were on the same page was seven years ago, and the three have never held formal three-way talks. However, the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit being held in Shenzhen has created a rare opportunity for the leaders of China, the United States and Russia to sit together. This sideline meeting, scheduled to be held on the last day of the summit, received even more attention than the summit itself.

On the international political table, this kind of meeting is more than just catching up on old times.

From nuclear weapons to artificial intelligence, from Ukraine to the war in Iran, a series of global hot topics may appear on the discussion agenda of the three. Although some U.S. officials have hinted that the war in Ukraine will not be discussed at this meeting.

"The fact that they can sit down shows that the world has not yet reached the situation of World War I or World War II." Ding Xueliang, emeritus professor at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, told the BBC.

But the meeting also raised some concerns. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky publicly stated last month: "We never want to see the situation evolve into some kind of 'Yalta 2.0, 3.0 or 4.0,' leading to a redrawing of spheres of influence." Diplomats from Japan and South Korea reportedly expressed concerns.

So, as global trade protectionism heats up and geopolitical competition intensifies, will Shenzhen witness a multilateral summit that builds consensus in the Asia-Pacific, or will it become a gaming field for the three major powers to redraw the boundaries of power?

End of Hot Reading

What do the "Big Three" want?

On Wednesday, on the tarmac of Shenzhen Airport, Putin's IL-96 and Trump's Air Force One arrived in the early morning and afternoon. Although this capital of science and technology in southern China has already entered a state of tight security and many roads were blocked, there are still a large number of citizens watching and waiting on the roads where the motorcade passes.

In May this year, Trump and Putin visited Beijing. However, in the eyes of many observers, being able to attend the APEC summit and hold trilateral talks between China, the United States and Russia still has symbolic significance for Moscow in breaking through its diplomatic isolation. This is evident from the fact that the Kremlin took the lead in releasing the "US-China-Russia Summit" in October this year.

Since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, relations between Moscow and Western countries have continued to deteriorate. Putin was issued an arrest warrant by the International Criminal Court, which made him absent from many large-scale multilateral meetings that he originally attended in person. Foreign visits are also mainly concentrated in strategic partner countries in Asia.

"Putin is the one among the three leaders who is most likely to benefit from this meeting," Aaron Glasserman, a researcher at the China Analysis Center at the Asia Society Policy Institute, told the BBC. He said that Putin needs to show the country that Russia is still a major country on an equal footing with the United States and China.

For the Kremlin, the political picture of the talks could be an outcome in itself. Gao Shiming believes that if images or statements from the meeting make the outside world believe that Washington has accepted Russia’s claim to sovereignty over part of Ukraine’s territory or that it will no longer support Ukraine’s resistance, it will be a major diplomatic victory for Moscow.

But Washington's eyes are clearly elsewhere. The White House stated before the summit that Trump would discuss the issue of "reducing global nuclear weapons" with Xi Jinping and Putin, and believed that the proliferation of nuclear weapons was extremely dangerous.

The last major legally binding strategic nuclear weapons limitation treaty between the United States and Russia - the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New START) - expired on February 5, 2026. This means that for the first time in more than half a century, the two countries are no longer subject to legally binding limits on the number of strategic nuclear weapons.

Trump proposed as early as his first term that he hoped to establish a new set of nuclear arms control arrangements and include China in the negotiations, because China's nuclear arsenal is undergoing rapid expansion. However, Beijing continues to reject this proposal, believing that the United States and Russia should first significantly reduce their own nuclear arsenals before discussing the participation of other nuclear-armed countries.

Gao Shiming said that Trump hopes to create an image of himself as being able to promote peace and maintain global stability through direct contact with the leaders of the two major powers. After the Republican Party suffered a disastrous defeat in the midterm elections and lost control of the House and Senate, a symbolic diplomatic victory would help him demonstrate his diplomatic achievements at home.

"After all, preventing Tehran from acquiring nuclear weapons has become the main excuse for the United States to engage in the costly and unpopular war with Iran," he added.

Many experts interviewed believe that Beijing is unlikely to give in easily on the issue of nuclear weapons. Ding Xueliang said that this is a "pipe dream" in the eyes of China, which pursues pragmatism. Gao Zhikai, deputy director of the China Globalization Think Tank (CCG), said that Trump's nuclear negotiations are a continuation of the negotiations between the United States and the former Soviet Union. For China, they are "compare apples to oranges."

Some analysts believe that Xi Jinping will gain the least benefit from this meeting. This is also the reason why China did not confirm until Monday that it would hold a tripartite meeting. A spokesman for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs continued to say that Beijing "maintains communication with relevant parties."

"Xi Jinping is committed to showing that China has become the center of global power, but compared with Putin, he has limited benefit from this meeting. After all, he has participated in many high-profile summits this year." Gao Shiming said.

The new "Yalta"?

Next to Xiangmi Lake, the Shenzhen International Exchange Center, the main venue of the APEC Summit, is like a roc spreading its wings. Behind it is the Futian financial and business core area with numerous high-rise buildings. This city is the starting point of China's economic take-off and is also regarded as the most successful symbol of China's reform and opening up.

The authorities clearly want to use Shenzhen to demonstrate their national strength—not just in the past and present, but also in the future. A group of technology companies that emerged from Shenzhen now play key roles in global industrial and technological competition.

This may also explain why the meeting between the leaders of China, the United States and Russia triggered completely different interpretations. Some see hope for stability, but others, including Zelensky, worry it will become another Yalta moment.

In 1945, the leaders of the United States, the Soviet Union, and the United Kingdom divided their spheres of influence in the Crimean city of Yalta, laying the foundation for the postwar international order. But the meeting also became a symbol of the big powers bypassing the smaller ones and deciding their fate in private.

At that time, China was the party whose destiny was decided. In exchange for the Soviet Union's war against Japan, the United States and Britain agreed to grant Moscow special rights in China. However, as an ally in the anti-fascist war, China was excluded from these negotiations and had no knowledge of the relevant arrangements.

"The decision made in Yalta back then harmed China's national interests." Gao Zhikai told the BBC. "So China will never follow this old path."

More importantly, analysts believe, although the three major powers may be sitting at the same table, it does not mean that they share a common vision of world order. "Their interests are different and sometimes even conflicting," Gao Shiming said.

"Xi Jinping needs to find a balance between demonstrating his status as a great power at home and opposing hegemonism internationally. If China is seen as working with the United States and Russia to carve up spheres of influence, or intervening in other countries' internal affairs, this will be very detrimental to international perceptions," Gao Shiming said.

He pointed out that this was especially true with regard to Ukraine. Beijing wants to avoid further alienating European governments as it continues to negotiate trade and investment issues with the EU.

This may explain why Beijing seems to be lagging behind on the Ukraine issue. After visiting Beijing last month, German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier said that Xi Jinping "seemed a little confused" when he asked him about the issue of ending the war in Ukraine that would be discussed at the China-U.S.-Russia summit.

"You could see the displeasure on his face. He even asked where these rumors came from," Steinmeier said. "He made it clear that this is a European conflict and Europeans themselves must be involved in solving it."

"Because Beijing knows that having more influence on the world comes at a price," Ding Xueliang said. He said that although China hopes to become a "big country" and a "powerful country", "its calculations have always been very clear."

He cited the Iran conflict as an example. Although China is an important buyer of Iranian oil and the war between the United States, Israel and Iran has severely damaged China's interests, Beijing "will never choose to directly intervene in a military conflict."

Will it be fruitful?

Despite this, when reporting on this summit, many international headlines still often used "the first time in history" to describe the handshake between the top leaders of the three nuclear powers of the United States, China and Russia.

Dr. Jue Wang (transliteration), a senior lecturer at Leiden University, believes that given the influence of the three countries in nuclear security, international conflicts and global strategic stability, the three-party talks have important geopolitical symbolic significance. But she said the actual impact still depends on whether a concrete agreement can be produced.

"It is not one of the goals of this meeting to reach an agreement between the three countries," she told the BBC. "Because this tripartite meeting was held on the sidelines of APEC, it is not a mechanism used to negotiate major geopolitical or security agreements."

Others believe that after Trump suffered a heavy defeat in the mid-term elections, many of his foreign policy decisions will face stricter scrutiny from Congress, which will limit his actual room for action, especially on his Russia policy.

"If Trump makes further concessions to Russia, he will face huge domestic political resistance." Gao Shiming said.

Although this meeting is unlikely to produce substantive results, Wang Jue believes that while competing strategically, the United States and China still have important "common interests", including AI security, clean energy, epidemic prevention and control, international trade and supply chain resilience, and the fight against transnational crime.

"These are areas where the two countries can cooperate without giving up technological competition or resolving fundamental political differences," she added.

concerns of small countries

Even if the meeting does not ultimately reach a substantive agreement, the reactions from Kiev to Tokyo and Seoul are enough to show that in today's increasingly fierce geopolitical competition, many small and medium-sized economies are worried that their voices are becoming weaker and weaker.

Zhuang Jiaying, associate professor at the Department of Political Science at the National University of Singapore, said that if the world becomes dominated by different major powers in different regions, this will reduce the autonomy space of small and medium-sized countries. Another dilemma they face is that international law and international organizations have "continued to be hollowed out by powerful countries" in recent years.

For example, he gave the example that under Trump's leadership, the United States withdrew from the Climate Convention and significantly cut funding to United Nations agencies, which had a direct impact. China, on the other hand, is weakening it indirectly, such as ignoring the South China Sea arbitration ruling and continuing to build islands in the South China Sea. Russia even directly invaded Ukraine.

"The system that was established for a long time after World War II was originally binding on big countries to a certain extent, and allowed small and medium-sized countries to be at least legally equal to big countries to a certain extent. But when this system is weakened, the bargaining power of small and medium-sized countries will be significantly weakened," Zhuang Jiaying told the BBC.

Some argue that this does not mean smaller countries have become irrelevant.

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is one of them. In January of this year, when he gave a speech at the Davos Forum, he called on the middle powers to unite because "if it is not on the table, it will be on the menu."

The idea also has support from Canberra. Foreign Minister Huang Yingxian also said in a speech that middle powers are working hard to promote a balanced pattern "to ensure that no country is dominant."

However, small and medium-sized countries do not have to passively respond to competition from big powers. Although it is difficult for them to compete with major powers in terms of military and political influence, major powers cannot ignore their role in the global economic system. Whether it is commodity markets, critical minerals, or regional supply chains and trade networks, small and medium-sized economies occupy an important position.

Yuen Yuen Ang, Chair Professor at Johns Hopkins University, focuses on political economy and development research in China and emerging markets. She told the BBC that regional trade relations were only growing in importance to Beijing.

"Chinese leaders recognize that the golden age of globalization has ended, and trade protectionism and geoeconomic competition have become the new normal." She said that because China is still highly dependent on overseas markets, Beijing has stronger incentives to promote regional trade cooperation.

Gao Shiming also has a similar view. He believes that although the meeting between the leaders of China, the United States and Russia may seem to dominate the APEC summit, for China, the relationship with its trading partners is very important.

"There is growing global opposition to the economic and social consequences of globalization. However, China's dependence on overseas markets has reached an unprecedented level," he said.

Trade between China and Southeast Asian countries reflects the depth of this economic connection. In 2020, ASEAN surpassed the United States and became China's largest trading partner. The proportion of Chinese goods in the ASEAN import market will increase from 10.6% in 2005 to 25.5% in 2024.

At the same time, a report released by the ASEAN Secretariat and the United Nations in 2025 showed that from 2020 to 2023, more than 75% of ASEAN's key mineral exports went to China.

"The biggest significance of what is happening in Shenzhen is that the world is still inseparable from international cooperation." Ding Xueliang said. "This is not eighty years ago."

Explore more

More short films

More short films end

US-China-Russia Summit: Why Choose Qilin Villa in Shenzhen? Both Xi Zhongxun and Kim Jong Il have stayed at

The 250th Anniversary of the Founding of the United States: Five Little-Known Historical Details of China-U.S. Relations

Xi Jinping's visit to the United States: What do the United States and China gain from the "Xi-Trump meeting"?

Before the APEC summit, a US think tank analyzes the details and limits of Sino-Russian military-industrial cooperation under "technological nationalism"

APEC Shenzhen Summit: Xi Jinping went to the airport to greet Trump, the first time in 46 years that a Chinese head of state received him at the airport

How does the U.S.-China energy war affect your bills?

headlines

Jen-Hsun Huang’s extramarital affair sparked the “Chinese spy” meme: Between humor and prejudice, how do Asian women deal with it?

Special recommendation

Popular content