Image source, EPA

Nepal's Foreign Ministry has announced that Nepalese Prime Minister Balen Shah will visit India on 22 and 23 November at the invitation of Indian PM Narendra Modi.

India has said that this visit shows the priority being given to Nepal under its 'Neverhood First Policy'.

Diplomacy experts say that there is a lot of curiosity in India about Balen Shah's official visit and his visit is being closely monitored.

Prime Minister Balen Shah was a rapper-turned-mayor of the capital Kathmandu and came to power through elections following a youth movement.

Experts in Nepal and outside Nepal consider him a non-traditional politician.

'Important turning point in India-Nepal relations'

Image source, EPA/RSS

This is why his first direct conversation with India's top political leadership upon his arrival in Delhi next week is being keenly watched.

Due to the great importance of bilateral relations between Nepal and India, there is curiosity about this visit.

There have been many ups and downs in relations between Nepal and India in recent years.

End

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

With the Rashtriya Swatantra Party coming to a decisive position in power politics in the last general elections in Nepal, some leaders of the party believe that the 'era of anti-India nationalism' is over in Nepal.

Balen Shah, who assumed power in March 2026, participated in the United Nations General Assembly held in New York to present Nepal's point of view on the global stage after the devastating floods in the Bhotekoshi river.

It is said that he had accepted India's invitation soon after assuming power and now he has chosen India as the first stop of his bilateral foreign tour.

Harsh V. Pant, Vice President of New Delhi-based think tank 'Observer Research Foundation', considers this visit as an important turning point in Nepal-India relations.

He says, "Balen Shah represents the new generation of leaders in Nepal and has been elected with a strong mandate. He has indicated his willingness to achieve concrete results in matters of national sovereignty and economic development. Therefore, this could be the door to a new opportunity for Nepal-India relations."

Pant says, "This is also a challenge. Because India will have to learn to adjust to a new kind of leadership. I think both Nepal and India will watch this visit with caution."

However, there is limited understanding of Balen Shah as a political figure in India. But Indian policy makers are also trying to understand him as a PM and his personality, because he seems to adopt a path different from the traditional diplomatic style.

Pant says, "Balen Shah is seen as a Nepali nationalist who is willing to show give-and-take and strategic autonomy. This is why both sides can find ways of practical cooperation to take mutual relations forward."

"But the challenge is whether his government will be able to translate the mandate of nationalist politics into a result-oriented relationship with India without compromising Nepal's sovereignty."

“These issues are going to persist for a long time. I think there is an opportunity here. But there is also a perception that perhaps India has not yet understood Shah properly, because he is a new player in Nepalese politics.

'The first big test of Balen Shah's foreign policy'

Ashok Mehta, an expert on Nepal-India relations and retired Major General of the Indian Army, says that very little is known about Balen Shah in India.

Pointing out that there was an atmosphere of suspicion about Shah due to some of his past public statements, he said, "He is not a very popular personality in India. This visit to India will be the first big test for him on the political and foreign policy front. Given his background and keeping in mind the statements he made during the discussion on the border dispute in the Nepali Parliament, he had also talked about talks with Britain. While he was mayor, he had talked about 'Greater Nepal'. Like other foreign leaders, he also talked about India. Was severely criticized."

He said, "This is the reason why there is a kind of distrust about him in India. There is also a sense of mystery about his personality. At the same time, there is also a curiosity to know and understand him."

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi had called Rashtriya Swatantra Party (RSP) President Ravi Lamichhane and leader Balen Shah to congratulate them on winning almost two-thirds of the seats in the general elections held last February.

There were also reports that immediately after assuming power, Balen Shah had not given an appointment to the Indian Foreign Secretary citing protocol, due to which the Foreign Secretary's visit to Kathmandu had to be cancelled.

However, after the visit of RSP President Lamichhane, Foreign Minister Shishir Khanal and Finance Minister Swarnim Wagle to Delhi, Prime Minister Balen Shah has reviewed some of his policies.

He had discussed many issues including his visit to Delhi with Indian Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri, who reached Kathmandu two weeks ago.

Nepali officials are appreciating the help received from India after the severe flood in Bhotekoshi river last August.

He has expressed hope that this tour will help India in reconstruction.

Will new chemistry be created?

Image source: Safal Prakash Shrestha/JNA Press/Nexpher Images via Getty Images

Former Indian Ambassador to Nepal Manjeev Singh Puri believes that the first direct meeting between the Prime Ministers of the two countries will be very important.

"National interests are paramount, but personal relationships and mutual understanding are equally important. India has always been a strong supporter of Nepal and has stood by it as an even stronger ally in times of need," he told the BBC over phone.

Describing cooperation between neighboring countries as important, he said, "Respect and mutual understanding towards each other at the leadership level is very important. When relations are good, no matter the complexity of any issue, its solution can be found. There has been a change in Nepal and a new leadership has come there. This leadership has taken the initiative by giving importance to India and India has also given equal importance to it. This is creating a new relationship of mutual coordination and we are trying in this direction."

Describing India's outlook towards Nepal as positive, former Ambassador Manjeev Singh Puri said that a very young Prime Minister is leading the government there, hence India needs to know more about Balen Shah.

He said, "I think he (Balen Shah) knows a lot about us. He has studied in India. He has also lived in India and understands us very well. His sister is also married here. I think he will have to show political understanding here."

Ashok Mehta, an expert on Nepal affairs and retired Major General of the Indian Army, also says that it is very important to maintain mutual trust at the top leadership level.

He said, "There is a huge age difference between the Prime Ministers of the two countries. It may be difficult to bridge this gap in terms of political coordination. Both will want to ensure that they can trust each other."

Foreign policy of the new government

Retired Major General Ashok Mehta said that India has concerns about Nepal's declared balanced foreign policy and Nepal's relations with China and America.

He said, "Nepal's dependence on India is more than 10 times its dependence on China. Therefore, along with balanced relations, the issue of geographical location and dependence should also be reviewed."

He said, "The Indian government will not say this directly, but it would like to get the same commitment from Nepal as it has got from the Sri Lankan government. It seems that India wants Prime Minister Balen Shah to make such a statement during his visit to Delhi, which can reassure the Indian government."

But Pant, vice president of Observer Research Foundation, believes that if relations between Nepal and China progress in a transparent manner, then India will not have much objection to it.

He said, "If we move forward by striking a balance between the opportunities offered by China and India's concerns, India will not have much objection to it."

Ashok Mehta said that now America has also become an additional challenge in the relations between Nepal and India.

He said, "At present, relations between India and America are at their lowest level in the last several decades. Earlier for America, relations with Nepal used to be a part of the broader scope of its relations with India, but now it is not so. This is another difficult aspect."

Pant says that India does not want Nepal to become too dependent on any one country.

He said, "Some administrations of the US want to work closely with India while working in this region, while some do not want that. There is tension between India and America. But I think both want Nepal to be stable, economically prosperous and to have diverse relations with different countries. America is sometimes a like-minded partner and sometimes not. But India can accept this and move forward."

Earlier, during the government led by KP Sharma Oli, coolness was seen in the relations between Nepal and India.

At that time, many Indian analysts had accused the Oli government of being inclined towards China, although Oli and his party denied this.

Some experts like Pant hope that with the coming to power of a new political force in Nepal, India can get rid of the situation of repeatedly getting entangled in disputes like in the past.

He said, "Governments in both countries are headed by powerful leaders. If both the leaders can agree on their views, then due to the political stability seen in both the countries, progress can be made on many issues in the coming years."

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

How experts are viewing Balen Shah's India tour

Live, when Siraj did not get a place in the team, Imran Masood raised questions, what answer did Rijiju give?

What is the political meaning of Azam Khan's 'beard and Hyderabadi biryani' statement?

must read

most popular