Image source, ANI

A minister of Pakistan government has visited India after three years, but his visit is not untouched by controversies.

Pakistan's Climate Change Minister Musadiq Malik is in Delhi to participate in the first 'Dialogue of Civilizations' of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO).

However, India's main opposition party Congress is not happy with Mussadiq Malik's visit to India.

Musaddiq Malik has reached New Delhi on Friday to participate in the meeting. He is the first Union Minister of Pakistan to visit India after the year 2023.

Earlier in 2023, the then Foreign Minister of Pakistan Bilawal Bhutto had come to India to participate in the meeting of SCO Foreign Ministers.

Opposition party Congress has accused the Modi government of adopting a soft attitude towards Pakistan regarding the visit of Musadik Malik.

Indian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said, "This is a multilateral forum under the SCO, in which all member countries, observer countries and dialogue partners have been invited."

This conference started on 20 November and will continue till 22 November.

End

what did congress say

Image source, X/@ClimateChangePK

Before the conference, Congress issued a statement saying, "Pakistan's Minister Musadiq Malik has come to India on the invitation of Modi government."

"Musaddiq has been continuously issuing threats to India. Sometimes he threatens to cut off his hands, and sometimes to shed blood. On one hand, Pakistan is promoting terrorism in our country and killing Indian citizens, while on the other hand, the Modi government is busy hosting a Pakistani minister who hates India. Preparations are being made to serve biryani and kebabs for him."

"There should be no talks with Pakistan until it completely ends terrorism. This is a betrayal of the country and its citizens."

It is noteworthy that India has many times accused Pakistan of playing a role in the extremist incidents taking place on its soil. Pakistan denies these allegations.

Pakistan also accuses India of instigating rebellion in its country, especially in Balochistan. India also denies this allegation.

Strong reaction from Congress

Image source: NurPhoto via Getty Images

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

Senior Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinet said, "The question is that Pakistan is accused of supporting terrorism, yet the Modi government is welcoming its representatives. Why can't your work be done without Pakistan being anti-India?"

Commenting on this, analyst Indrani Bagchi says, "Congress is doing what the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) once did to it. This is not going to benefit any political party."

"Elections are going to be held in the states in a few days. In such a situation, such statements will become louder. This is an aspect of our politics."

On November 18, during an event at the University of Chicago, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, in response to a question from a Pakistani student, had also said, "Pakistan supports terrorism in India."

Rahul Gandhi had said that due to these allegations it is not possible to start talks between the two countries.

According to Indrani Bagchi, the stances of Congress and BJP on the issue of Pakistan have become similar to a great extent. Both parties consider the end of terrorism as the basic condition of talks.

However, he says that this does not mean that representatives of the two countries do not talk to each other on multilateral forums.

She says that contacts are a common thing in the meetings of international organizations like SCO, but the issue of Pakistan always remains prominent in Indian domestic politics.

"The phrase kebab-biryani was earlier used by BJP, now Congress is using it for BJP. Whenever the name of Pakistan comes, political parties try to use it for their benefit."

What is Civilizational Dialogue?

Image source, ANINEWS

The concept of 'Dialogue of Civilizations' i.e. dialogue between civilizations was introduced by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Its purpose is to promote dialogue, understanding and mutual harmony instead of conflict between different civilizations.

The historic Old Fort of Delhi was chosen for the inaugural ceremony of the conference. This fort, built by Mughal emperor Shahjahan, is considered a symbol of historical and cultural diversity, because remains from different eras have been found here.

India's Union Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat said on this occasion that there is very little scope for disagreement between the two countries on cultural issues.

"The development of Pakistan's culture and civilization is not different from ours. It has not even been 100 years since we were separated. They have also developed with us."

Speaking to journalists on the sidelines of the conference, Pakistan Minister Musadiq Malik said, "This is a great opportunity for multilateral dialogue on civilizations and cultures."

"Cultures and civilizations transcend borders. So it is welcome that we are discussing our history, geography, cultures and civilizations here."

When asked whether such contacts were expected to improve relations between Pakistan and India, he said, "I am sure all our relations will improve. You know the region is going through a period of change and the fundamentals of geopolitics are changing very rapidly."

“I hope we will look at things from a broader perspective and advance the region's common agenda through discussions on geopolitics, poverty and all other issues.”

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

Nepal PM Balen Shah's first visit to India, is this a new beginning of friendship?

Live, Khadoor Sahib MP Amritpal, who was in Assam jail for 3.5 years, reached Punjab.

Major success in the treatment of pancreatic cancer, which is being called 'the biggest progress in decades'

must read

most popular