image copyrightEPA
Assistant to the Russian President Yuri Ushakov said that Moscow did not agree to the participation of European countries in peace negotiations in Ukraine. Four days ago, White House representatives Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner announced after a meeting with Vladimir Putin that Moscow does not object to Europeans joining the negotiations. Meanwhile, Ukrainian leader Vladimir Zelensky said that the United States discussed with him the idea of exchanging Donbass for Ukraine's membership in NATO.
“Someone is talking about expanding the format [of negotiations], but this has not been agreed upon with us,” the Russian Interfax agency quotes Ushakov’s answer to the question of whether European representatives will participate in the next round of negotiations.
“In order for this to be agreed upon, a lot of things will need to be done,” Ushakov added, “and, in particular, it’s probably possible to go through another and perhaps more than one round of trilateral negotiations.”
On November 10 and 11, the next round of negotiations took place in Abu Dhabi between the delegations of Ukraine, Russia and the United States. It was reported that in addition to ending the war, the parties also intend to discuss the architecture of European security. The only result of these consultations, as in previous times, was preliminary agreements on the exchange of prisoners of war.
After their visit to Abu Dhabi, Witkoff and Kushner went to Moscow for talks with Putin and then spoke with Zelensky in Ireland.
On November 12, immediately after meeting with Putin in Moscow, Steve Witkoff told reporters: “The Europeans will join us at the next meeting, which we think is a big deal, because it’s important: they are our partners, it’s important for them to participate [in the negotiations].”
Jared Kushner wrote on the X Network on November 13, after he and Witkoff met with Zelensky: “We have made meaningful progress in understanding what both sides care about, identifying possible solutions and a path forward. Both sides agreed to expand negotiations in the next round to include our European partners.”
But a Putin aide said Monday that Europe does not have clear and meaningful proposals for a peace settlement.
End of Most Popular
“When we receive clear signals from the Europeans about what they actually want and what they can constructively and meaningfully offer for the success of a settlement in Ukraine, then the question will probably arise about their participation,” Ushakov told reporters, answering a question from Interfax.
Trilateral negotiations again, but now with Europe, the USA and Ukraine
Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova said on the same day that, as far as the Russian foreign ministry knows, the issue of involving Europeans was not discussed at the meeting between Witkoff and Kushner with Putin.
Photo copyrightPA Media
This extension will help if you have difficulties accessing the BBC Russian Service website.
Download extension
End of story Chrome browser extension - link
The majority of EU representatives and the leaders of individual European countries take a much tougher position towards Moscow and the war it unleashed compared to Donald Trump and his special representatives. Therefore, Moscow considers Europe a less convenient interlocutor even at the current, purely preliminary, “technical” stage of negotiations.
“I don’t know which of the current [European] leaders can be a sane interlocutor,” Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said on Monday.
Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky said on November 15 that a meeting of the “coalition of the willing” this week would, in particular, formulate a “strong European position for negotiations.”
“The trilateral format - Ukraine, America, Russia - should become not just a quadrilateral format, but also an order of magnitude stronger,” Zelensky said.
He previously told reporters that Witkoff and Kushner reported after their meeting with Putin that all sides agreed to include the Europeans in the negotiation process, and that he had asked the Europeans to decide by the end of November who they would include in the delegation.
European countries at an informal enlarged EU summit in Dublin on November 12-13 decided that the continent would be represented in the negotiations by the national security advisers of the European Union, four of its countries - Germany, France, Italy and Poland - as well as the national security adviser to the prime minister of non-EU Great Britain.
On Monday, Zelensky said via social networks that the three parties to the “technical” negotiations - Ukrainian, American and European - had a conversation.
“Europe was represented for the first time in this conversation in full by those who will represent it in negotiations with the Russians. These are France, Germany, Britain, Italy, Poland, representatives of the EU, that is, the European Commission and the European Council, and a representative of NATO,” Zelensky said.
“The conversation was not easy, but there is a result: in Berlin, within the framework of the Coalition of the Willing, we will meet and work out concrete joint steps in the negotiation process,” Zelensky added, without explaining why the conversation turned out to be difficult.
NATO in exchange for Donbass?
Despite numerous rounds of negotiations, Russia and Ukraine are no closer to agreements to end the war. Judging by numerous publications, the main obstacle remains Moscow’s demand for the withdrawal of Ukrainian troops from the entire territory of Donbass, even from those areas that Russian troops did not occupy. Ukraine does not agree with this and demands strong security guarantees that could prevent a new full-scale war.
On Saturday, Vladimir Zelensky said that recently the United States for the first time mentioned the possibility of joining NATO in exchange for leaving Donbass.
“The Americans posed the question: “And if Ukraine is in NATO, will Ukraine leave Donbass?” This was the first time. We are discussing with our partners a comprehensive security package that they can offer us during negotiations: specific security guarantees from NATO and the EU, a strong Ukrainian army,” the Interfax-Ukraine agency quotes Zelensky.
“If there is such a proposal, I, as president, will enter into an open dialogue with society and say: “Look, this is where we are, this is how all the partners have united, and this is how they see it further.” Of course, without any recognition of the occupied territories by Russia,” the President of Ukraine continued.
US representatives have not yet commented on Zelensky’s statement.
Russia categorically objects to Ukraine's entry into NATO and cites its intention to join the North Atlantic Alliance as one of the reasons for the war.
Axios reported that American mediators asked the Moscow representative for updated proposals, and not the demands made at the end of 2021 before the start of Russia’s war against Ukraine.
Following European leaders, Zelensky rejected Russia's proposal to conclude a sweeping agreement on a "security architecture" before specific terms for ending the war in Ukraine were agreed upon.
“The order of action should be this: ceasefire, end of the war in Ukraine, security guarantees for Ukraine. You cannot turn everything on its head and first talk about changing the security structure in the world or on the continent as a whole, and only then talk about the end of this war and security guarantees for Ukraine. First we need to end this war,” Zelensky said.
Does Moscow want NATO to retreat in Europe?
On November 14, the New York Times reported that two days before Witkoff and Kushner’s visit to the Kremlin, the Russian side put forward its demands to the United States, including the refusal of military cooperation with the West not only by Ukraine, but also by a large group of other countries in Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus and Central Asia, which were formerly part of the USSR or its Eastern bloc.
Photo copyright: Reuters
The demands were outlined in an unsigned document dated November 10. The New York Times writes that it received its text from one of the participants in the negotiations, and another source confirmed its authenticity. In diplomatic practice (including Russian), such documents are called the English term non-paper: they set out the position of the state, but without obligations on its part.
Overall, the November 10 document differs little from the draft treaty that Russia published in December 2021 shortly before the start of its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. It stipulated that the entire NATO military infrastructure should be withdrawn to where it was located before 1997 (that is, beyond the borders of the former Warsaw Pact). Russian diplomats demanded that all provisions of the document be accepted without discussion.
The differences between the new document and December 2021 concern only a few details, notes the New York Times: if in 2021 Russia demanded that the United States not share its nuclear capabilities with its European allies, now a similar demand has been made to the other two NATO nuclear powers - Great Britain and France.
It is separately stipulated that Western countries should not supply any military products to Ukraine. Ukraine's accession to the European Union is permitted, but only on the condition that it does not take part in its defense component.
New York Times interlocutors admit that such a maximalist position is Putin’s initial gambit at the negotiations on the “security architecture of Europe,” at which he may later make some concessions.
End of Subscribe to our social networks and newsletter
Download the new BBC World Service app!
When you first open the app, select "BBC News Russian Service" and receive notifications about important news, analysis, videos and podcasts.
Important: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
Find out more
Video playlist
End Video playlist




