Image copyrightReuters

Alex Phillips, Anna Horrigan (The Hague), and Jonathan Head, Southeast Asia correspondent

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) handed down a judgment on the 19th in which Gambia, a West African country, sued Myanmar on behalf of Islamic countries for genocide committed against Myanmar's Rohingya Muslim minority. This is the first time in history that the ICJ has certified genocide by a state.

Presiding Judge Yuji Iwasawa found that Myanmar had an "intent to destroy" a substantial portion of the Rohingya population and had committed "extensive destruction of evidence" to cover up the crime.

The ICJ noted in its ruling that approximately 10,000 Rohingya were killed and more than 700,000 were forced to flee the country as a result of the military's crackdown in Myanmar between 2016 and 2017. Buddhists make up the majority of the population in Myanmar.

The Myanmar government rejected the ICJ's ruling, claiming that the military was responding to an attack by an armed group.

Image provided by EPA

The ICJ ruled that "the only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the evidence presented was that there was genocidal intent".

The ruling was handed down by judges from around the world, with nine votes in favor and six against. The ICJ also found that Myanmar violated several other provisions of the 1948 Genocide Convention.

Gambia's lawsuit against Myanmar centered on the so-called "clearance operations" that took place from 2016 to 2017 in the western Rakhine state, where many Rohingya people lived.

After Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) fighters attacked more than 30 police stations in Rakhine state, leaving scores dead, Myanmar's military, supported by local Buddhist insurgents, attacked Rohingya villages one after another. Many Rohingya tried to flee the country at once.

Rohingya refugees testified that entire villages were burned and civilians massacred. Numerous survivors and witnesses also testified that Myanmar's military raped and abused Rohingya women and girls.

The ICJ found that approximately 10,000 Rohingya were "violently killed" during the clearance operations. It also found that more than 700,000 people appear to have fled to Bangladesh on foot or by sea, and that around 815,000 people had been targeted in some way.

image copyrightGetty Images

Judge Iwasawa said Myanmar's military had committed "indiscriminate" killings, executed men, "wide-ranging" sexual violence, "extreme violence" against children, set fire to Rohingya homes and attacked Rohingya who were trying to flee to Bangladesh.

The presiding judge also said Myanmar had engaged in "massive concealment of evidence" by incinerating and disposing of bodies, incinerating and bulldozing sites, and failing to prosecute those responsible for the violence.

While acknowledging the impact of ARSA's actions, the ICJ determined that there was an "overlap" between anti-Rohingya hate speech campaigns in Myanmar that portrayed the Rohingya as "subhuman beings" and "violent threats" and clearance operations that increased the likelihood of violence against the Rohingya.

Myanmar's government has consistently denied genocide against the Rohingya, saying it was responding to the ARSA attack on a police station in an operation targeting extremist and rebel threats.

Government representative Ko Ko Hlaing told the ICJ in January that the country has no obligation to "stand by and allow terrorist activities to go unchecked." Following the verdict on the 19th, he said, ``I have no comment.''

The ICJ also investigated the various treatment of the Rohingya in the lead-up to the clean-up operation. It ruled that policies such as limiting Rohingya households to two children were discriminatory and aimed at violating the rights of Rohingya.

The ICJ also ordered Myanmar to pay compensation. The specific amount will be determined at a later date.

"Acknowledge our suffering"

The Rohingya community and human rights organizations welcomed the ICJ's ruling.

"Our suffering has been officially recognized," said Mohamed Noukim, a Rohingya. "The Rohingya have been waiting for justice for decades," said Noukim, who was forced to leave Rakhine state in 2017 and now lives in Canada.

Human Rights Watch (HRW), a human rights organization, said the ruling "finally recognizes the suffering that the Rohingya people have endured."

UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk said the Rohingya's "suffering, misery and humiliation" "leaves a stain on the conscience of humanity". Furthermore, he emphasized that the ICJ's ruling "needs to become a concrete action in the future."

To convict the Myanmar government of genocide, it was necessary to establish not only that a horrific act had been committed, but also that government officials or state institutions intended to partially or completely destroy the group.

The ICJ ruling is unprecedented and gives Myanmar the stigma of being the first country to be found to have violated the 1948 Genocide Convention.

Since the Genocide Convention was established in response to the Holocaust committed by Nazi Germany, the ICJ has only ruled twice in the past on claims of genocide by a state. In both cases, the ICJ has ruled that there is insufficient evidence to attribute the act of genocide to the state.

Genocide is considered the most serious crime under international law. Dozens of individuals have been convicted of genocide, but establishing that the act was directed by the state requires stronger proof than other charges.

Image provided by EPA/Shutterstock

Philip Sands, a prominent British human rights lawyer who helped bring the case, called it a "historic decision."

"This is comparable to great moments in international justice, such as the Nuremberg trials and the Pinochet trial," Sands told BBC Radio 4. The Nuremberg Trials refer to the trials of Nazi leaders held after World War II, and the Pinochet Trials refer to the trials of the Chilean dictator.

However, since the ICJ is not a criminal court, its enforcement powers are limited. Myanmar military personnel cannot be imprisoned and must rely on the United Nations Security Council and political pressure to enforce sentences.

Meanwhile, this ruling will also have an impact on other genocide cases being tried at the ICJ. This includes a lawsuit brought by South Africa over Israel's war in Gaza.

Sands said during the ICJ hearing that the case against Israel was "an issue that everyone knows about but no one talks about."

Sands said that the ICJ's decision regarding Myanmar does not necessarily mean that it would issue a similar ruling regarding Israel's attack on Gaza, but that if the ICJ had found that Myanmar was not responsible as a state, the case against Israel "effectively would have ended."

Israel says the lawsuit against it is "totally baseless."

Antonia Mulvey, director of the non-profit organization Legal Action Worldwide, told the BBC that the ICJ did not accept the Myanmar government's claim that the military's actions were counter-terrorism, and was the first to recognize rape and sexual violence as acts of genocide. He said this would serve as a legal precedent and would be considered in future litigation.

A US State Department spokesperson said that the "proper interpretation" of the Genocide Convention was "critically important" and that "preventing the politicization" of the ICJ was equally important. "We are reviewing this judgment to fully assess its impact," the spokesperson added.

The State Department said it shares "grave concerns about the continuing human rights violations against Rohingya Muslims and other ethnic minorities," adding that the United States is "the largest donor of humanitarian assistance to Rohingya refugees."

In response to the ICJ ruling, British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband announced that the government would order Myanmar's defense attaché to be expelled from the UK and summon the chargé d'affaires.

The foreign minister pledged to take "further steps in the coming days to ensure those responsible are held accountable" after a cross-party group of MPs called on the government to reinstate sanctions on Myanmar's military.

(English article Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya minority, top UN court rules)

See more

Allegations of genocide against the Rohingya in Myanmar begin trial at the International Court of Justice

ICC Prosecutor's Office seeks arrest warrant for Myanmar military chief over Rohingya persecution

The Rohingya continue to be persecuted in Myanmar, both by the military government and by anti-regime armed groups.

International Court of Justice orders 'stop genocide' of Rohingya; Myanmar protests

International trial over Rohingya genocide begins, with Aung San Suu Kyi appearing in court

Rohingya genocide Myanmar soldier was supposed to be sentenced to 10 years in prison, but he has been released

video

Video, US and Russian presidents shake hands, President Xi looks on with a smile at APEC summit, Duration 0,31

Video, BBC report from the Kiv bridge attacked by Russia "Battle for the Bridge", duration 1,14

Video, Trump says 'we won' Iran war at Veterans Day ceremony, duration 1,02

Video, US Secretary of Defense Hegseth and his aides are reprimanded by guards for silence at Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, Duration 0,33

Top articles

The leaders of the United States, China, and Russia announce a “peace declaration” after historic talks.

Myanmar military commits genocide against Rohingya, International Court of Justice declares

Ukraine attacks Crimean bridge for third time in a week, Russian authorities say

Reading material/commentary

Featured articles