Image source: Skanda Gautam/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
Nepal Prime Minister Balen Shah's visit to India has raised hopes of a new beginning in relations.
This is being considered as the first high level dialogue between the leaders of the new political generation of Nepal and India.
This is Shah's first bilateral foreign visit after his party Rashtriya Swatantra Party (RSP) came to power in March.
RSP came to power six months after the fall of KP Sharma Oli's government due to the Gen Z movement against corruption and nepotism.
36-year-old rapper-turned-politician Balen Shah is reaching Delhi on Sunday on a two-day visit to India. During this, he will meet his Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and other senior officials.
Many issues are expected to be discussed in the talks. These include economic and energy cooperation, opening new air corridors and a reconstruction aid package after the devastating flash floods that hit Nepal in August.
More than 1,450 people died in this disaster in the Himalayan country Nepal. Hundreds of people are still missing and their whereabouts have not been found.
India and Nepal have deep ethnic, cultural, religious and economic ties. There is more than 1,750 km long, almost open border between the two countries.
End
Nepal is a strategic buffer country situated between India and China. Analysts say that Nepal's stability has a direct impact on India's security.
But relations between the two countries have been strained over the decades due to border disputes, allegations of political interference and resentment over Delhi's attitude, which many in Nepal consider a 'Big Brother' attitude.
Shah's visit an opportunity for a new beginning
Image source: Ryan Murphy/Getty Images
Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava
Learn more
Nevertheless, analysts believe that this visit of Shah can become an opportunity for a new beginning in relations.
Former Indian ambassador Ranjit Rai told the BBC, "Nepal's new leadership says it is not burdened by the political baggage of the past. It wants to focus on development, diplomacy and economic partnership."
"They seem to be more practical and less ideological. I personally think this is an optimistic moment," he said.
In 2008, Nepal abolished the monarchy and adopted the form of a democratic republic. Since then, three political parties have dominated the politics and governance of the country.
Delhi has maintained close contact with these three parties.
These include Communist Party of Nepal (CPN-UML), Nepali Congress and Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist Centre).
Nepal's communist parties have been considered closer to India's rival China due to ideological ties. These parties have often been criticizing Delhi for those bilateral agreements, which they consider to be inequitable.
Due to Nepal's strategic location, both Delhi and Beijing try to increase their influence in Kathmandu. This often leads to allegations that these two big powers of Asia are interfering in Nepal's internal affairs.
But relations between Nepal and India are not limited to just diplomacy and strategic interests.
There are deep social ties between Hindu-majority India and Nepal. People from the same families live on both sides of the open border of the two countries and there is daily interaction between the communities.
Bilateral trade between the two countries is more than 9 billion dollars. However, a large part of it is in favor of India, about which there has been dissatisfaction in Kathmandu for a long time.
India is a major supplier of petroleum products and many food items to Nepal. Apart from this, India is also an important transit route for Nepal's trade with other countries of the world.
An important area of cooperation is hydropower. India has approved projects to import up to 1,200 MW of power from Nepal and plans to increase this further in the future.
Ranjit Rai says, "There is a huge demand for electricity in India and Nepal has a huge potential to generate electricity due to its water resources and geographical location. This is not limited to just bilateral cooperation. Nepal also exports electricity to Bangladesh via India."
India has often been among the first countries to provide help during major natural disasters such as the 2015 earthquake and the flash floods in August this year.
Border dispute issue expected to arise
Image source: Getty Images
Despite close relations, there have also been differences between Nepal and India.
In 2019, Nepal got angry when India published a map. In this map, those areas in the western region near the Chinese border were shown as part of India, which Kathmandu also claims. After this incident, awareness about that area had increased in Kathmandu.
This diplomatic dispute further increased after Nepal released its own separate map. Those disputed areas were also included in the map of Nepal.
Nepal's senior political analyst Kanak Mani Dixit told the BBC, "I hope that this time the Prime Minister of Nepal will raise the issue of border dispute with Delhi. It may not be resolved immediately, but talks should start to resolve this problem."
Nepal has been demanding India to open additional air entry routes for a long time. With this, bigger aircraft will be able to reach the new airports located at Bhairahawa and Pokhara from the west.
Bhairahawa is located near Lumbini, the holy place of Buddhism. Pokhara is a major tourist center of Nepal.
By getting access to Indian airspace, the time of flights will be reduced and the cost will also reduce. Also, when more flights start, these airports will become commercially profitable.
Some people in Nepal also believe that Delhi is cautious about the fact that Gautam Buddha International Airport was built by China's Northwest Civil Aviation Airport Company. Pokhara Airport has also been built with the financial assistance of China.
Shah has not yet given any overt diplomatic signal towards Beijing. But before traveling to India, he sent a 20-member delegation of his party's MPs to China on an 11-day visit from November 15.
This is being seen as an attempt to maintain balanced relations with Nepal's two powerful neighbours, India and China.
Shah had promised not to travel abroad in the first year of assuming office. But the devastating flash flood in August has changed the situation.
His government estimates that reconstruction will cost around $5 billion. Whereas the international aid announced so far has been less than expected.
How ready is Shah to visit India?
Image source, ANI
However, some observers of Nepal believe that Shah's preparations for this important visit to India have not been adequate.
Kanak Mani Dixit says, "Prime Minister Shah and his advisors are young and new, but they lack experience. Many times they have shown a lack of seriousness in governance, whereas this is very important for diplomacy with such a powerful neighbor."
Shah is also facing criticism regarding some recent government decisions. These also include the removal of Police Chief Dan Bahadur from the post.
It is alleged that he had refused to follow the instructions of the Prime Minister's Office.
Police were sent to detain journalists in some news organizations. This action was taken due to his news. After this there were allegations of curbing the freedom of the press.
Kathmandu has ambitions to further its relations with India. But the real test for Shah will be whether he returns from this trip with concrete achievements.
If they get a clear and concrete commitment from Delhi on financial assistance, it will be considered a diplomatic success. This can also help in reducing the increasing criticisms within the country to some extent.
Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.
Download the new BBC World Service app
Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place
Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
short video
end of short video




