image copyrightGetty Images
On February 24, 2022, just hours after Vladimir Putin launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine, he convened a group of Russia’s wealthiest people in the Kremlin’s cavernous Yekaterininsky Hall.
More than thirty people sat huddled together along the wall, wearing masks due to the COVID-19 pandemic. One Russian newspaper reporter described them as "pale and sleep-deprived." After Putin entered the venue, he sat down at the other end of the hall, leaving a large space between him and these businessmen. As usual, he was not wearing a mask.
In characteristically cryptic terms, he said he expected them to support the war.
"I would like to appeal to you to understand what is happening," he said, "and to work with the government to find tools to support production, the economy and employment."
In a video of the meeting released by the Kremlin, none of the invited billionaires spoke.
This silence has become a hallmark of Russia's super-rich. Over Putin's decades in power, they have learned that speaking out can be costly. In 2003, oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky, then Russia's richest man and a bankroller of various opposition groups, accused Putin of condoning rampant corruption. He spent the next decade in prison, convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement - a warning to other would-be critics. He denies the accusations.
image copyrightALEXEY NIKOLSKY/SPUTNIK/AFP via Getty Images
Even if there are tycoons who oppose the war, they often keep their thoughts to themselves.
But even amid the silence, there are whispers: Some among Russia's once-powerful business elite appear to be imagining a "post-Putin" Russia. They wonder whether, once the president leaves office or dies, the country will look more like it did in the 1990s, when oligarchs enjoyed the fruits of power - or whether a healthier politics might take hold.
End of Hot Reading
Journalist Arkady Ostrovsky, a well-known Kremlin watcher for The Economist magazine, recently spent several hours interviewing one of Russia's richest men. He said he senses "a historic political shift is taking place" in how the super-rich view the country's future.
restless tycoon
The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 gave rise to a powerful new force on the domestic scene: those who took advantage of the end of communism to become extremely wealthy and then sought to manipulate politicians to their own advantage. They were called oligarchs - a word derived from ancient Greek meaning "rulers of the few". They had money, and back then, money meant power.
The "wild nineties" were the era when the so-called "new Russians" emerged. Large state-owned enterprises are up for grabs, and those with connections become millionaires—even billionaires—almost overnight. Corruption is rampant, nepotism is rampant, and murders are frequently committed.
But after Putin was first elected president in 2000, he almost immediately subdued these oligarchs. He has little interest in sharing power with anyone. The reason why he has the confidence to be tough on these billionaires is because the Russian economy is recovering and the central government is getting stronger.
image copyrightNurPhoto/NurPhoto via Getty Images
Financier Bill Browder, once Russia's largest foreign investor, was banned from entering the country in 2005 for launching an anti-corruption campaign. He said Russian tycoons shrank in Putin's presence - such as at the Davos economic forum in the pre-war years, when they were still popular there.
"I remember seeing these oligarchs walking around looking like masters, the most arrogant, confident guys. And then once Putin came along, it was amazing to see how these so-called 'alpha males on steroids' turned into absolutely obedient, almost desperate schoolboys," he told the BBC.
Since the outbreak of war in 2022, the Kremlin has used a ruthless carrot and stick policy to restrain Russia's wealthy businessmen. Critics of the war watched their assets confiscated, while loyalists were rewarded with lucrative government war contracts: Russia now has more billionaires than ever before (155 in total, according to Forbes magazine). Their combined wealth has reached an all-time high of nearly $700bn (£525bn).
But even for the tycoons who stayed loyal and reaped the rewards, the money didn't seem to make them happy. Some people are getting restless.
Autocracy, oligarchy or democracy?
Their billions are not as useful as they once were: they can't buy much political influence at home.
"They have no cards and no game to play," said Dmitry Nekrasov, an exiled politician and analyst. "They are rich because they are associated with Putin, not the other way around."
Outside Russia, they are ostracized due to Western sanctions imposed in the wake of Russia's full-scale invasion.
"They are treated like low-level criminals. Their private jets can't fly. Their yachts can't dock in all the best ports in Europe. It must be very bad and very humiliating for them," said Browder, a public critic of Putin.
So some of them began quietly thinking about what would happen after Putin left the scene. That's what some veteran analysts familiar with the world of these tycoons told me.
The president shows no sign of leaving office anytime soon, and there is no reason to think he is in poor health. But Putin, who turned 74 last month and has been in power in the Kremlin for 25 years, knows in Moscow that his exit will one day come. Asked by Reuters last year whether he planned to stay in office until 2036, when his constitutional term technically ends, Putin replied: "Only God knows whether our health is enough."
image copyrightCARL DE SOUZA/AFP via Getty Images
If Putin resigns or dies in office, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin will take over. But Mishustin has shown no presidential ambitions (which was presumably the key reason for his appointment). This will create something of a power vacuum.
In this case, Russia watchers I spoke with envisioned several possible scenarios.
Some in the West - and no doubt some in Russia - hope that a post-Putin Russia will see the flowering of democracy, with a government led by the people rather than a new batch of oligarchs or another dictator. But analysts say that appears to be the least likely path. Under Putin, key democratic institutions have been eroded or destroyed. "Russia is so used to violence that it is no longer used to standard democratic procedures," said Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian journalist and analyst.
The other path is more autocracy. Another figure could replace Putin and continue his culture of repression. But Prokopenko doesn’t think this will be another strongman dictatorship — at least not right away. These things take time, she said: Initially, Putin's successor will be weaker than him and command fewer resources.
There is a third possibility: the tycoons reassert power and Russia returns to a system similar to the oligarchies of the 1990s. Nekrasov, a former Kremlin adviser and opposition politician now in exile, said that in this scenario the country would be governed by a handful of powerful elite families aligned with business interests.
This last option is naturally what many tycoons want. “They want to go back to a time when they were listened to, their assets were not taken away, and they understood the rules of the game,” Prokopenko said. She spent a lot of time talking to Russia's richest people.
Although their power has been severely reduced since the 1990s, these tycoons are still worth listening to: given their vast wealth, sooner or later they will try to reassert their political influence.
Exiled politician Nekrasov said there were already some "trying to make friends with the right security officials or ministers." But he said any further action was "too dangerous to take".
image copyrightVladimir Smirnov SPUTNIK/KREMLIN POOL/EPA/Shutterstock
He said the behavior of tycoons in the coming years will depend in part on their financial health. People with large amounts of liquid cash on hand will be more confident to "play political games" and compete for position, preparing the country for the post-Putin era. But those whose wealth depends on state contracts or government goodwill will feel too scared for fear of losing everything, he said.
Prokopenko said there has been a shift in the way businessmen talk about Putin. They used to nickname him "Nachalnik" ("boss"), "Perviy" ("first"), or just his initials "VV" - all of which conveyed a certain level of respect. Now they call him "Ded," with, in Prokopenko's words, "a hint of contempt." "Ded" translates as "old man" or "grandpa" - a far less respectful title.
She said some wealthy Russians yearn for "politics to return to people's lives" with less repression, more open speech and healthier competition between parties and politicians.
But right now, she says, they are too scared to make this happen because of the stifling atmosphere in Russia. Prokopenko interviewed one tycoon who kept his phone sitting underneath him throughout the conversation because he believed it would make electronic eavesdropping by the secret police more difficult. "I think it's an absolutely Stalinist fear. It's completely irrational," she said.
an explosive interview
An interesting clue as to what tycoons might want from a post-Putin future comes from Andrey Melnichenko. He is known as the "World Fertilizer King" and is currently the 8th richest man in Russia.
Earlier this year, he surprised observers by giving an interview to The Economist — a rare move for a wealthy Russian, especially one from a publication in a country the Kremlin views as unfriendly. The journal also published an article written by him.
In parts of the interview, Melinichenko repeated the Kremlin's rhetoric. He said Ukraine was a battleground between Russia and the West, which he believed was ignoring Russia's security concerns and threatening its sovereignty.
But then it gets even more interesting. Melnichenko stopped short of calling for Putin to step down, but — and this is a big “but” — he advocated changes to end one-man rule in Russia. Russia needs to engage more with the world, he said.
Prokopenko believes the tycoon is trying to stir up a public discussion. It's "a call for wealthy people like him to start speaking out," she said.
The journalist who interviewed him, Arkady Ostrovsky, told me that the two had "intense and heated discussions" in "hotels and cafes, mostly over coffee, a lot of coffee, sometimes smoking." He said the tycoon seemed to be "thinking hard" about his answer rather than offering politician-like PR rhetoric.
Nothing is ever simple in Russia, and most observers believe the interview likely had some form of Kremlin approval — either tacit or explicit. We don’t know why the authorities were willing to approve this unusual call for change; it’s possible they were trying to show that some degree of pluralism still existed in the country.
No tycoon came forward to support him. However, this reporter felt that Melinichenko was not only speaking on behalf of himself, but also on behalf of his business colleagues.
image copyrightAndrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Journalist Ostrovsky said some of them hope that after Putin leaves, the country can become an "oligarchic republic" - like it was in the 1990s, with a business elite in power.
Drawing on years of experience covering Russia, Ostrovsky said many of the country's super-rich now feel "a sense of complete desperation and that this war has brought Russia... into (a) situation where there is no future."
But even as tycoons are thinking about the future, the chances of them taking action anytime soon appear slim.
Browder, a Putin critic, said that while many of them were disaffected, they were unlikely to plot against Putin while he was still alive. "They understand that if they do anything to challenge Putin, he will kill them. And Putin is a very suspicious little guy."
Mike Calvey, an American financier who has been a major investor in Russia, agrees. "What can they do but go straight to jail and lose their assets? It's easy for people sitting in London to say, 'Why don't you all stand up and just go to jail?' That's what's really going to happen."
Russia's richest men were once able to pull strings at the highest levels of power. With Putin gone, they will undoubtedly try to regain their former influence. The question is: will the remnants of the current regime allow them to do this?
Title image source: Getty.
This article was originally written in English. We used artificial intelligence to assist in translation and was reviewed by BBC journalists before publication. Learn more about how we use artificial intelligence.
Explore more
More short films
More short films end




