Credit, Reuters

The fiscal adjustment proposal presented by the economic team last week, while President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (PT) was carrying out an agenda outside the country, displeased many people — and for very different reasons.

Analysts at banks and financial institutions considered the measures insufficient to continuously reduce the rate of increase in expenses and rebalance the government's accounts.

"In our view, the proposals contribute to an adjustment in the short term, but do not resolve the trend of structural growth in public debt and fiscal deterioration," Rachel de Sá, strategist at Research XP, the analysis and research area of ​​XP Investimentos, wrote in a report sent to clients.

On the other hand, groups on the left attacked the initiative, saying that it served the interests of the financial market and defended a greater focus on fundraising. There were several demonstrations on social media and even within the government base itself.

"What if instead of giving in to Faria Lima's blackmail, we approved measures that make banks and billionaires pay the bill for fiscal adjustment?", wrote deputy Lindbergh Farias (PT-RJ) when sharing an interview in which he proposed increasing taxes on corporate profits and dividends and taxation of exempt investments and large fortunes.

The Complementary Law Project (PLP) 299/2026 for fiscal adjustment provides for measures on both ends, to reduce expenses and increase revenues, with an estimated impact of between R$43 billion and R$54 billion, and integrates the effort of the economic team so that the primary result (the difference between revenue and expenses, without accounting for financial expenses, such as payment of interest on the debt) is a surplus in 2027.

The Brazilian government recorded primary deficits (i.e., spent more than it collected) in practically every year since 2014, with the exception of 2022, the last year of Jair Bolsonaro (PL) as President.

Voting in the Senate, which began last Thursday (12/11), should be completed this Tuesday (17/11), then passing to the Chamber of Deputies.

End of Most read

Credit, Lula Marques/Agência Brasil

Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service

Download here

End of app promotion

The topic, in fact, is divisive. Even among economists, views can be quite different when it comes to government accounts, their impact on public debt and the cost of that debt — interest.

On one side are those popularly known as liberals, orthodox, who tend to see the issue in a similar way to that which prevails in the financial market, which has repeated that a structural reduction in the rate of increase in expenses is unavoidable to control debt and prevent the country from heading towards a crisis.

On the other side, heterodox economists known as developmentalists react by drawing attention to the negative impacts of spending cuts on the lives of the most vulnerable and on the economy itself and defend an adjustment to increase revenue collection.

The division is not absolute and the labels leave out the nuances — developmentalists who defend some type of expense adjustment, for example — but they help to situate the voices in the discussion.

BBC News Brasil spoke to analysts and researchers with different points of view on the subject and brings the debate in the report, which gains even greater relevance at the current moment, on the eve of the beginning of the fourth Lula government, when the direction of economic policy over the next four years is still unknown.

What economists agree on

In his first address to the nation after being re-elected, the president went so far as to say that "the trajectory of public debt and high interest rates" worried him, but he did not detail how he planned to attack the problem, beyond reaffirming the promises to expand social programs and investments made during the campaign.

Hence the doubt about the features of the economic policy of the Lula 4 government, which has roots in the president's own history.

In the first term (2003-2006), with Antonio Palocci at the Treasury and Henrique Meirelles at the Central Bank, the government even raised the primary surplus target to 4.25%, a much higher level than the 0.5% stipulated for 2027, and kept interest rates high to contain inflation, a policy in line with what usually pleases the market.

In the second (2007-2010), with Guido Mantega, the emphasis changed to stimulating growth via public investment, with the Growth Acceleration Program (PAC) and the response to the 2008 crisis.

The third term (2023-2026) combined a little of both: it expanded social programs, but created a new rule to limit the growth of spending, the fiscal framework, which replaced the spending ceiling approved under Michel Temer's government and was criticized on the right for being too loose and on the left for being restrictive.

In any case, the discomfort expressed by Lula on November 8th is shared by the majority of economists.

In general, both sides recognize that the country's public debt has advanced at a faster pace than the economy in recent years. Central Bank data shows that, since the end of 2022, the General Government Gross Debt (DBGG), which includes federal, state and municipal governments, has risen by more than 11 percentage points, from 71.7% to 82.9% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP).

Brazil owes R$11.1 trillion. Creditors are all those who bought the country's debt securities: private and public investors, inside and outside the country.

Economists in general also do not disagree that the main reason for the increase in debt, mathematically, is high interest rates.

The basic interest rate for the Brazilian economy, Selic, which is established by the Central Bank, is 13.75% per year. Discounting inflation, it remains at a level above 9%, the highest real interest rate in the world.

Part of the debt is adjusted by the Selic, which also influences the behavior of other rates on debt securities.

Interest expenses totaled R$1.205 trillion in the 12 months ended in September, equivalent to 8.99% of GDP, a very high percentage. For comparison purposes, in 2025 the Union collected R$2.89 trillion in taxes and other revenues.

What the government collects has not been enough to cover its expenses — payment of pensions and benefits, civil servants' salaries, funding for the SUS and federal universities.

Considering the entire public sector, the primary deficit was R$94.3 billion from January to September, around 0.93% of GDP, according to data from the Central Bank.

Taking into account interest (R$882 billion) in the same period, the so-called nominal deficit, the volume of resources that the government needs to raise from the market jumps to R$976 billion.

The two deficits lead the government to borrow more money, but as interest expenses are substantially higher, this is what deepens the debt.

And this is where economists from different schools of thought separate themselves: they agree that high interest rates are a problem, but they disagree about why they are high — and the remedy.

Focus on spending

Liberal economists claim that interest rates are high largely because there is an imbalance in the government's accounts. The high rate is the premium for the risk of lending to a country that spends more than it collects; which, in theory, would have a greater risk of defaulting.

In this line of thought, to reduce interest rates it would be necessary to convince investors that accounts will improve, so that they accept lending to the government charging lower interest rates.

The director of macroeconomics for Brazil at UBS GWM, Solange Srour, argues that a broad adjustment is needed, which provides a "credibility shock" that could open up space for the Central Bank to cut interest rates in a sustainable manner.

"We need to create primary [surpluses] of the order of 1.5%, 2% of GDP, not 0.5% of GDP. So, if it's more of the same, I think the interest rates demanded by the market will rise", he assesses.

The economist says that a "broad adjustment" would not be anything like what the president of Argentina, Javier Milei, implemented in the country. One of the reasons is the design of the Brazilian budget itself, in which a large part of the expenses are mandatory and can only be changed through a Proposed Amendment to the Constitution (PEC).

This adjustment would be ambitious and implemented at the beginning of the government, but its impact would be gradual, says the economist.

“I also don’t think it’s right to make indiscriminate spending cuts,” she adds.

"What needs to be done is a broad review of the designs of social policies, because we have spent a lot on social policies, but, at the same time, we are not seeing such a rapid and significant drop in poverty and inequality", adds Srour.

The assessment is similar to that of economist Marcos Mendes, associate researcher at Insper.

"If you look at the data, there has been a brutal increase in expenses, especially with social programs, since the end of the pandemic. And, despite this, we have almost 10 million people in extreme poverty, and in a context in which GDP has been growing", he points out.

Mendes criticizes, for example, the expansion of the Pé-de-Meia program, which began as financial aid for low-income high school students, with the aim of combating school dropout. The government announced that it will extend it to all public school students from 2027 and create a version for low-income university students.

"Did they make any assessment about the cost-benefit of this expansion? They didn't. Then they promised a nest egg scholarship for university students, but there are dropouts at universities, is it the same problem in high school? It's not. They're distributing money", he assesses.

"So the quality worsens, the focus of [social] policy worsens."

Both also defend decoupling social spending and Social Security benefits from the minimum wage. Today, none of these benefits can be lower than the national minimum, and that is why they automatically increase whenever the minimum is readjusted.

The two economists also argue for decoupling mandatory spending on health and education from revenues. The Constitution obliges the government to allocate to each of these areas minimum amounts linked to percentages of what enters the public coffers, after making some deductions.

"Whenever revenue rises, expenditure rises along with it. So, even if you try to make a fiscal adjustment by increasing revenue, part of this increase in revenue turns into an increase in expenditure and nullifies your fiscal adjustment effort", says Mendes.

Both measures are criticized by economists on the other side of the debate. The argument is that the adjustment of Social Security benefits at the same rate as the minimum wage — which, in turn, is also readjusted by a policy that foresees real increases every year — would be an important mechanism for social protection and reduction of inequalities.

In the case of linking health and education, the idea would be that an increase in revenue would allow an increase in spending, which would be positive as they are two essential public services.

"Who is interested in reducing public spending on health and education? [It's] those who compete with public provision of health and education and those who don't need public health and education", says Pedro Paulo Zahluth Bastos, head professor at the Institute of Economics at the State University of Campinas (Unicamp).

“It’s a distributive choice,” he adds.

Focus on revenue

Bastos is co-author of a manifesto released shortly after the elections that proposes as a counterpoint to market pressure for adjustment and which, according to him, has more than 20 thousand signatures at the moment.

The manifesto proposes a series of measures, including an adjustment focused on increasing revenue, and not on cutting or slowing down the increase in expenses. Primary surpluses would be achieved by achieving "tax justice", with measures such as the review of exemptions, special regimes and incentives for the private sector and the end of super salaries in the public sector.

The idea is based on the assumption that the trajectory of expenses alone would not be a problem. On the contrary, from a developmental point of view, government spending would induce economic growth — another striking difference from the liberal view of the economy, which argues that public spending can "take space" from private investment and that the sustainable expansion of activity is the result, for example, of productivity gains.

"The public sector, in general, is 33% of the economy, the Union alone is around 20%. If the government cuts its spending, this will have a multiplier effect on private spending: government spending is a demand for the private sector, if the private sector receives less demand, it produces less, sells less and invests less", he states.

Credit, Jamil Bittar/Reuters

For Bastos, high interest rates in Brazil cannot be explained by a government fiscal imbalance. He points out that countries with a primary deficit at similar levels, around 0.5% of GDP, and with a similar level of foreign exchange reserves (considered high, around US$365 billion, and which in practice reduces net debt) have significantly lower interest rates.

"It is not possible to say that it is the primary deficit that explains the size of interest rates, because, when compared internationally, it is not [compatible]", says the economist.

The high level of interest, for him, is a reflection of a "political convention", historically constructed by groups that are interested in high interest rates because they make money from them.

This effect would be greater here than in other emerging countries, for example, because the "power of financial elites in Brazil is greater than in other places".

The professor also states that the financing risk of Brazilian debt is low because it is mostly in local currency, in reais. Countries with a high level of external debt, such as Argentina, for example, are vulnerable to exchange rate fluctuations, which can suddenly increase the level of debt, and depend on the level of their foreign exchange reserves, as they need dollars to pay the debt and interest.

"This discourse that there is a great debt risk is always linked to the demand for higher interest rates, and it is an interested discourse, it is not a neutral discourse", he states.

Among the measures proposed in the manifesto that could allow the Central Bank to reduce interest rates is the increase in the inflation target from 3% to 4.5%, a level that was in force between 2005 and 2018. As monetary policy aims to control inflation, the higher target would give the Central Bank space to reduce interest rates.

Economists with a liberal bias are critical of measures like this, arguing that increasing the target results in a loss of credibility for the Central Bank, with negative impacts on market expectations regarding the inflation trajectory and the increase in long-term interest rates.

The Central Bank does not have direct control over long-term interest rates, which are set by the financial market for long-term loans based on expectations related to the future behavior of the economy.

If agents believe that inflation will not converge to the center of the target, and later on the BC will be forced to raise interest rates to deal with high inflation, long-term interest rates will incorporate this perception, with real negative impacts on activity, with credit becoming more expensive.

Not just cuts, not just taxes

There are a series of proposals halfway between the deeper adjustments to expenses advocated by the market and those focused mainly on increasing revenue advocated by its critics.

In a study prepared for the Institute of Studies for Industrial Development (IEDI), economists Manoel Pires and Bráulio Borges, linked to Ibre FGV, proposed a list of measures to control the fiscal deficit with "the concern of not producing any type of rupture or interruption in essential public policies".

Among them is the reduction of the real increase in the minimum wage from up to 2.5% to 1% and the change in the rule for minimum health and education spending from being linked to income to a percentage that recomposes inflation and guarantees a 0.4% real increase.

The director of the Independent Fiscal Institution (IFI), Alexandre Andrade, assesses that "the ideal would be to combine an adjustment on the revenue side and on the expense side".

The IFI is a technical body linked to the Senate that publishes periodic reports on the fiscal and debt situation. In June, the institution projected that, if current conditions were maintained, the debt would exceed 100% of GDP in 2032 and reach 115% in 2036.

"I think the projection has to be seen more as a sign, an alert that changes need to be made", points out Andrade.

The IFI has drawn attention to a growing volume of expenses that have not been considered in the calculation of the primary result, but which also have a fiscal impact and contribute to an increase in debt. The most recent report points out that measures like these reduce transparency and can erode the credibility of the tax regime.

Andrade points out that the third Lula government focused on increasing revenue, and succeeded. He negotiated with Congress the gradual end of payroll taxes, which will be completed in 2028, for example, and introduced taxation on exclusive and offshore funds.

He argues, however, that the country already has a high tax burden, "and there is a lot of resistance from society to new increases" in taxes.

He sees room for revenue gains in so-called tax expenditures, tax benefits and revenue waivers for companies that the Federal Revenue estimates total more than R$600 billion.

Even so, Andrade assesses that it is also necessary to contain the rate of increase in expenses, "some with growth above the limits of the fiscal framework, of 2.5%" in addition to inflation.

"The major expenditure aggregates are social security and assistance benefits. The expenditure on these benefits exceeds 50% of the Union's primary expenditure. So, inevitably, to think about any adjustment, [it would be possible to consider] rules that regulate access to these benefits or even correction", comments the economist.

He emphasizes, however, that he believes that "any adjustment needs to be legitimized."

"It is very difficult for us to talk about reviewing programs such as the salary bonus or any rules for accessing the BPC [Benefício de Prestação Continuada], if there are these others, let's say, these aberrations, such as tax expenses and super salaries in civil service, to give some examples", adds Andrade.

"So, ideally, an adjustment would need to achieve all of this to legitimize it and so that no sector of society feels unfairly treated."

Discover more

Watch

End of Watch

Debate on interest rates has everything to do with youth and popular mobilization that led Lula to victory, says André Singer

The worrying signs of the economy in 2027 and what Flávio and Lula propose for them

Brazil should not increase the minimum wage, but get rid of it, says economist John Cochrane

What is a primary deficit and how disputes in the Lula government affect your pocket

Top news

Why did Europe ask its citizens to make emergency kits?

What is the fiscal adjustment that the market demands from Lula? Understand why it displeases many people and divides economists

Is the blackout on November 17th true? Where did the theory come from and why is it unlikely?

read more

Most clicked