Credit, Marcello Casal Jr/Agência Brasil

At the age of 30, Isabella Pertsch from Santa Catarina decided to go to court to try to erase from her documents a record of someone who she considers never represented care, presence or affection for her.

Isabella no longer wanted to carry the surname of her biological father, who she describes as someone absent throughout her life.

Today, living in Germany for a decade, married and planning to have children, she explains that it is not just a bureaucratic issue. It's an attempt to end a story marked by emotional and financial abandonment: "I just want to put an end to this."

Stories like Isabella's are at the center of a relatively new discussion in Brazilian law: the possibility of removing the name of one of the parents from the birth certificate and other official documents.

There is no specific law that provides for this type of change, but recent court decisions have opened space for requests based on situations of emotional abandonment, violence or complete disruption of family ties.

According to Isabella, her biological father never effectively participated in her or her sister's upbringing, did not pay child support regularly and maintained an intermittent relationship with the family. The fear that he might, in the future, ask his daughters to take care of him in his old age was one of the reasons for his decision.

"I saw a case on the internet in which the father went to court against his children, even though he was never present, and I was desperate that my father could do this."

But there is also a symbolic aspect: every time she had to write her father's name on a form or even enter her paternal surname on official documents, Isabella says she felt as if she was reliving a connection that she prefers to leave behind.

End of Most read

"When my husband and I decided we wanted to be parents, one of the first things that crossed my mind was that my parent would appear in my child's family tree. I don't want that at all."

Your goal is to exchange your father's surname for your mother's surname. The process is ongoing, in the evidence production and witness testimony phase.

BBC News Brasil sought the defense of Isabella's father, so that he could provide clarification on the process and give his version of the facts, but he stated that he did not want to make any statement at the moment.

According to the lawyer responsible, his client "will await the developments in the process and the final pronouncement of the responsible Court".

Brazil is a pioneer: 'It's not on a whim, it's pain'

Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service

Download here

End of app promotion

Gustavo Silva, family lawyer who represents Isabella, explains that the possibility of asking to remove the name of the parents from public records is the result of the evolution of the concept of socio-affective affiliation.

"If it is possible to recognize someone without a biological link as a father, it is also fair that someone can no longer be recognized as a father when there is no emotional link", he states.

For lawyer Patricia Gorisch, director of the Brazilian Institute of Family Law (IBDFAM), the change reflects a broader transformation in the way the Judiciary views the family.

She argues that the name is no longer just a marker of family belonging to becoming a central part of individual identity.

"Today we have many divorced people, for example, who choose to keep their ex-partner's surname, because they already identify with him, without this meaning that they remain married", says Gorisch.

In his opinion, forcing someone to keep the name of a father or mother who caused suffering could mean reliving traumas repeatedly throughout their lives. "It's not a question of whim. It's a question of pain", he says.

This understanding, however, does not mean that anyone can simply delete their parents' names from documents or request the removal of a specific surname. The Court analyzes case by case, based on case law.

That is, there is no law or convention that provides for these possibilities, but cases have arisen across the country based on decisions taken by higher courts in recent years.

The oldest precedent is from 1997, according to the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) itself. In the decision published on December 9 of that year, the body authorized for the first time the exclusion of the paternal surname due to abandonment.

In a newsletter published in 2026, the STJ referred to this case as a landmark on the topic. Other processes, from 2003 and 2015, are also cited as examples.

Specifically, in the case judged 11 years ago by the Third Panel of the STJ, not only the suppression of the paternal surname was authorized, but also the replacement with the paternal grandmother's surname.

The agency also cites a more recent case, from 2025, in which the possibility of total extinction of the paternity bond was recognized for the first time, that is, the removal of the parent's name from individual documents.

"In this context, the possibility of suppressing patronymics, especially in the context of emotional abandonment, proves to be compatible with the centrality of affection in contemporary families and with the protection of the free development of the personality", said the STF in the information.

"Otherwise, the imposition of maintaining a surname with which the interested party has no emotional relationship goes against their personality rights, representing an identification that is not consistent with the reality they live in."

But, although Brazil is still building this jurisprudence, the country has adopted an approach considered relatively innovative when justifying these decisions, according to Patricia Gorisch.

According to the lawyer, some jurisdictions allow similar changes, such as certain American states, including California, which issues new civil registrations in specific situations.

However, the predominant trend around the world continues to be to preserve registration links of origin, even though there are mechanisms for changing surnames or adoption.

"When I participate in international forums, many representatives from other countries are surprised, because Brazil ends up being a great pioneer in this area", says Gorisch.

Credit, Getty Images

How does the process work?

The processes for terminating the paternity or maternity relationship or excluding surnames are not simple, according to the lawyers interviewed by the report.

It is necessary to prove the abandonment, whether economic or emotional, or the abuses suffered by the courts. For this, in addition to material evidence, credible witnesses are necessary.

As cases are analyzed on an individual basis, it is also not uncommon for requests to be rejected in lower courts.

For Gustavo Silva, this still happens because Brazilian public records legislation, created in the 1970s, was conceived under the logic that civil records are immutable.

"Some judges still maintain a more conservative view in relation to all this, basing themselves more on the law than on new jurisprudence", says the family lawyer, who has had his clients' requests denied in the past.

Critics of the changes argue that removing family ties from records could cause legal security and identification problems, as this type of information is used to determine inheritance rights, maintenance obligations and preventing marriages.

Patricia Gorisch disagrees and argues that removing the name of the father or mother does not exclude the name of the grandparents (maternal or paternal) from the certificate. Furthermore, the entire family history is kept by the registry office in a separate registry book, which is not public, but can be accessed by the interested party and the Court.

"If the person is getting married, for example, the notary will check the books to check if there is any incompatibility. This has been happening for years in the case of adoption."

Gorisch also explains that the removal of the parent's surname or even the exclusion of family ties does not necessarily imply the release of pension payments or loss of inheritance rights.

Isabella, however, wants to be excluded from any possibility of inheritance or future obligation to her father.

"I had already tried to look for my father to sign a contract that would remove me from his inheritance and take off my shoulders the worry of having to take care of him in his old age. He refused, and then I decided to file this lawsuit."

What about maternal abandonment?

The cases of requests for withdrawal of membership that reach the Court mostly involve fathers, not mothers.

"All the cases I saw being judged and being successful were cases of father, paternity, paternity deconstitution. Maternity deconstitution, I, at least, have never encountered", says Gustavo Silva.

Patricia Gorisch attributes this difference mainly to cultural factors. For her, the requests reflect a historical reality in which parental abandonment is more often associated with men than women.

"It's very much related to Brazilian, Latin American, machismo culture, right? Abandonment by the father is much more common than by the mother, even though it exists by mothers", he states.

Despite this, a case that gave considerable visibility to the search for children by removing the name of one of the parents from documents in Brazil involves the desire to deconstitute motherhood.

It is the story of Heloísa Rodrigues, 28 years old. On social media, the young woman says that she suffered physical violence, mistreatment and sexual abuse during her childhood and adolescence, and maintains that keeping her mother's name on official documents forces her to constantly relive this past.

She managed to change her name and remove her maternal surnames from the documents in court in 2024. However, he was denied the broader request to also exclude maternal affiliation from his civil records.

Her defense appealed to the São Paulo Court of Justice, and she is now awaiting a new decision.

Discover more

Watch

End of Watch

'Any type of mother is capable of abandoning her children. It's a matter of circumstance'

The man abandoned at birth who found a biological family 65 years later

'I was told he was dead': Children abandoned by British soldiers in Kenya discover the truth

Top news

The 'army of grandmothers': the numbers that show those responsible for the spike in turnout in the elections

Why the US lost its measles elimination certificate after 26 years

Vacations, military enlistment and 'fake trip' to New Zealand: the crazy things that 'GTA 6' fans are doing for the launch

read more

Most clicked