Credit, Rockstar
Many families' breakfast this Wednesday (11/19) may have been accompanied by an uncomfortable question: "Father/mother, why can't I play Grand Theft Auto VI, GTA 6, the biggest release in the history of video games?"
If we take into account the indicative rating of 18 years old obtained by the game's developer from the Ministry of Justice — due to the scenes of violence, sex and drug use present in the story —, the answer is simple: no.
In practice, however, the decision involves more complex dilemmas. How to deal with children of different ages at home? And when the parents themselves also want to have fun with the game? There is also a fear that restricting access to the game will end up excluding the child from conversations and interactions with friends at school.
For mental health experts consulted by BBC News Brasil, parents must respect the indicative classification.
"The classification is there for a reason. There is research behind why such games cannot be shown to this audience. The younger the child is, the more susceptible they are to the effect of media in general, not just games", says Livia Scienza, PhD in psychology from the Federal University of São Carlos, who studies the impact of video games on the behavior of children and adolescents.
"You are a thief in the game, and that is something we do not recommend for children and adolescents", adds psychiatrist Danielle Admoni, a specialist in childhood and adolescence at the Federal University of São Paulo (Unifesp).
GTA 6 follows a pair of criminals, Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos, on an adventure through the world of crime in the fictional state of Leonida, inspired by Florida, in the United States.
In this franchise, which has existed since 1997, the player can attack and kill criminals, police officers and civilians using firearms, knives, explosives and other objects. The attacks cause bleeding and can form pools of blood around the bodies. More powerful weapons can also cause decapitation and dismemberment.
End of Most read
Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service
Download here
End of app promotion
The player can also have sexual relations, go to strip clubs and touch the dancers' breasts. Regarding drugs, it is possible to smoke marijuana and consume cocaine — actions that in this new game negatively affect relationships between characters throughout the story.
In most European countries, the game was rated for people over 18 years old, the same age group adopted in Brazil. In the United States and Canada, the recommendation is for people over 17 years old.
In both cases, the rating is assigned by self-regulatory systems created by the games industry itself: the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB), in the USA and Canada, and the Pan European Game Information (PEGI), in Europe.
The difference occurs because, in the USA and Canada, the 17 age rating already allows content such as intense violence, blood, mutilations, sexual content and strong language. The adult restriction is reserved for games that generally feature prolonged scenes of intense violence or sex and real money gambling.
Credit, Rockstar Games/Disclosure
Dilemmas at home
In families where parents or older siblings also want to play, but do not have the privacy to do so, the psychiatrist argues that it is necessary to establish a dialogue so that everyone's individualities and needs are respected.
"We don't have sex with the door open, for example. How do we do it? We organize ourselves. In this case, it's a case of playing later, when the child is sleeping, or when they're not at home", says Admoni.
"People have children and want their children to adapt to them, but that's not how it works. It's the opposite: we are the ones who have to adapt to the children", adds the psychiatrist.
When pressure comes from outside the home — because classmates at school only talk about the game, and other families don't follow the rating —, Admoni says it is necessary to explain to the child why the content is inappropriate and make it clear that the restriction is intended to protect them.
"From this, you are already teaching something much bigger: rules and limits. You can't do everything you want. It's better to be a boring and careful parent than, in the future, having to chase after mental issues. If everyone is playing, everyone is wrong, and our role is to teach what is correct", says Admoni.
Psychiatrist Guilherme Polanczyk, coordinator of the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Service at the Institute of Psychiatry at Hospital das Clínicas de São Paulo, admits that imposing limits on children and adolescents can be exhausting, but emphasizes that this is part of raising a child.
He considers that, inevitably, children will have contact with the game's content, whether through digital influencers or through their schoolmates. This, however, is not the same as receiving parental permission to play, he says.
"Many parents will say that, somehow, their child will already be exposed to the content, so it's better to release it. But there's a difference: if you didn't allow it, they may even be watching it, but they know it's wrong," he says.
“These limits have a message behind them: that we do the right thing, that there is no room for the inappropriate, that there are things that are wrong and that’s it,” adds Polanczyk.
Admoni uses another example, quite common in many families, but which, in her opinion, should not be trivialized: children and teenagers who eat their meals in front of electronic devices, such as portable video games, tablets and cell phones, whether at home or in restaurants.
"Just because it has become normal for a child to have lunch with an iPad or cell phone in front of them, it does not mean that your children need to do this. This can lead to a series of problems with eating in the future", he says.
Do games influence children and teenagers? What science says
The arguments of those who defend a less restrictive stance on the part of parents are supported by research that questions the association between violent video games and aggressive behavior in real life.
In 2019, researchers from the universities of Oxford and Cardiff, in England, published a study in the scientific journal Royal Society Open Science with 1,004 British teenagers aged 14 and 15.
The results showed no relationship between involvement in violent games and higher levels of aggressive behavior.
Another survey, published in 2014 in the journal BMC Psychiatry, based on interviews with British children aged 7 to 11, identified that the majority were able to distinguish the violence portrayed in video games from real situations.
In general terms, these were also Scienza's conclusions when studying the possible effects of games on children and adolescents at UFSCar. She also highlights that this influence is not restricted to video games, and can come from any other type of media, such as films, series and cartoons.
"The literature indicates that children and adolescents who already live in vulnerable situations are more susceptible to this type of influence. The longer a child lives in violent communities, with early exposure to sex and drugs, the more vulnerable they are. Those who live in environments with more dialogue and attend school are less susceptible to this type of influence", he says.
The psychologist adds that "the biggest protective factor for children who play this type of game is having a guardian nearby, explaining that it is not legal, that it is fictional and that it should not be done in real life."
"It is also important to question why the child took a certain attitude at that stage of the game and, whenever possible, play with them", advises Scienza.
Credit, Getty Images
There are also those who argue that the problem is not necessarily in games, but in digital platforms such as Discord, where harmful content can circulate and young people can be encouraged to commit acts of violence ranging from animal abuse to rape.
For Admoni, however, concern should not be limited to the possibility of the child becoming more or less violent, but encompass other possible impacts on mental health.
She states that, although there is research that seeks to identify the effects of exposing children and adolescents to violent or sexual content, there is still uncertainty about its possible consequences.
Admoni emphasizes that each case is particular and that factors such as the child's life history, the way in which the exposure occurred and its duration can lead to different results.
Based on her clinical experience, however, she cites some possible harm. "We have seen psychotic conditions, obsessive disorders or post-traumatic stress. And long-term exposure even changes relationship characteristics: they become colder."
Polanczyk, from Hospital das Clínicas, adds that "being exposed to this content, especially for many days, many hours, shapes the vision" of children and adolescents.
"Eventually, they reproduce in real life those relationship patterns that they are experiencing in games. Often, they are teenagers who already have a component of aggression, irritability, may have depressive symptoms, and when exposed to this content the effect can be very harmful", he assesses.
There are also those who argue that games can produce positive effects, by showing that certain attitudes considered inappropriate have consequences.
There is, in fact, the expectation that GTA 6 will follow a trend observed in other recent titles and encourage the player to adopt positive behaviors.
In Red Dead Redemption 2, another industry success, the way the player interacts with the environment and characters influences an honor system associated with the protagonist.
According to the title's developer, Rockstar Games, the same company behind GTA, helping people in danger, sparing opponents and acting generously increase honor, while stealing or harming innocent people reduces honor.
Depending on your choices, therefore, the player may be treated differently by the other characters, who cannot be controlled by the player. Negative attitudes, for example, can make it difficult to resolve conflicts throughout history.
"Crime is a fundamental part of GTA. We're trying to make sure we don't punish players for playing the way they're used to, but their actions will have some effect on how the game plays out," said Rob Nelson, co-director of the Rockstar North studio, in an interview with British newspaper The Guardian.
Asked if GTA 6 would be the first title in the franchise to try to encourage some degree of empathy in players, Nelson responded affirmatively. "For the first time, we are trying to offer mechanisms that encourage this, for those who want it."
In any case, says the psychiatrist, it is not necessary to expose a child to a violent game to teach them what they should not do in real life. "You don't need to expose the child. You don't need to throw them in the middle of the street to teach them that they need to look both ways before crossing," he says.
Discover more
Watch
End of Watch




