Credit, Netflix/Disclosure

Ilana Casoy remembers the case of Suzane von Richthofen, portrayed in a new Netflix documentary, from when the young woman was not even accused of killing her parents — at first, the suspicion was that the family home had been robbed, and her parents had been killed by thieves.

The criminologist participated in all stages of the investigation and trial, while doing an internship at the São Paulo Civil Police, in 2002 — from the simulated reproduction of the crime to the popular jury that sentenced Suzane and the brothers Cristian and Daniel Cravinhos to decades in prison.

It is with this background that she states that the reason why people are enraged by the documentary — Suzane von Richthofen: What Time Doesn't Erase, released last week — is because they see themselves reflected in Suzane.

"They feel part of this story and react with a lot of hatred", says the criminologist.

"Society feels very betrayed by Suzane. Why? It's a white, straight, nice, middle-class society, and this girl was one of us. How does she do that? That's why I think the case gives rise to huge discussions — psychological, philosophical, social, educational, even biological."

Casoy gave her statement to the film and was a consultant for the production, helping the directors understand the case and interviewing other professionals involved in the investigation.

She also wrote a book about the case, The Fifth Commandment (Ediouro, 2006), and helped script three films that address the crime: The Girl Who Killed Her Parents (2021), The Boy Who Killed My Parents (2021) and The Girl Who Killed Her Parents: The Confession (2023), released by Amazon Prime Video.

Credit, Disclosure

The expert says that Suzane failed to redeem herself, if that was her goal. Sentenced to 34 years and four months in prison, Suzane was imprisoned in a closed regime for more than a decade and went to the semi-open regime. Since 2023, he has been serving the remainder of his sentence in an open regime, which should end in 2038.

End of Most read

Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service

Download here

End of app promotion

Since leaving the Tremembé Women's Penitentiary, 150 km from São Paulo, Suzane has traveled to some cities in the interior of São Paulo. Today, she is married, has a son and lives outside of prison, in an open regime.

In general, under this regime, the prisoner can live elsewhere, work or study during the day, but cannot travel or leave his home at night or on Sundays and holidays. The details of how Suzane serves the remainder of her sentence, however, are unknown, because the criminal execution takes place in secret from the courts.

"She will finish serving her sentence and, legally, she will be zero for zero. But moral judgment works differently. Will she be morally acquitted? There is no law that holds it back", says Casoy, commenting on excerpts from the interview that have gone viral on social media.

In one of them, Suzane starts laughing when telling the story of a prosecutor who supposedly fell in love with her and presented her with a McDonald's snack.

"Whoever kills can't laugh anymore, right? They can't be happy. This accompanies the conviction. The way they are morally condemned, what do you mean you're going to laugh? Shut up. You're not going to laugh in my face, right? You're not going to be happy. What do you mean you got married and have a child? Are you crazy? You don't deserve it", says the criminologist, when assessing the public's reaction.

Another reason that would be arousing indignation among viewers would be the speculation that Suzane had received a fee to give the interview that leads the film. Netflix said, in a note sent to BBC News Brasil, that it does not comment on details of its productions. Casoy, in turn, says he is amazed at this possibility.

"I never heard of it. I was inside [the production] and I never heard of Suzane receiving money," he says.

"I'm not peremptorily saying no, but I didn't have that information. I asked and it was always denied. Maybe I was the last to know, right? Making money from one's own crime is something I vehemently disagree with."

Credit, Disclosure

The Suzane case was one of those that made her a criminologist — a profession that today allows her to collaborate with investigators, prosecutors and defense lawyers, especially in the field of serial crimes and those linked to the family.

Then came cases like those of Gil Rugai, convicted of killing his father and stepmother in 2004, and the murder of the girl Isabela, thrown from a building in 2008, which led to the arrest of her father, Alexandre Nardoni, and her stepmother, Ana Carolina Jatobá.

In addition to providing consultancy in the police and legal sphere, Ilana writes books and scripts for films and series about these crimes.

His latest release is the book Rugai por Nós (Darkside Books), about Gil Rugai, who, although he was convicted by the courts, has his blessing — after having participated in his defense, alongside his son, who is a lawyer, Casoy says he investigated the case and believes in Rugai's innocence.

In the interview with BBC News Brasil, Casoy talks about the Suzane von Richthofen case and discusses the way Brazil has dealt with criminals and their crimes, including recent debates about increasing sentences and mass incarceration.

Read the interview below, edited for clarity and brevity.

BBC News Brasil — What does a criminologist do and how does he train?

Ilana Casoy — Criminology, in general, is within Law, but has interfaces with many areas. It's usually postgraduate, but there aren't many. I'm self-taught, until the Brazilian Institute of Criminal Sciences launched a two-year postgraduate course and, luckily, it didn't say that only lawyers could enroll. I threw myself. I learned a lot and formalized knowledge. It's a difficult career.

In my thesis, I delved into the philosophical, social, psychological and even biological issues of crimes. The idea is to understand how a crime can happen, what path the criminal takes, and there are very specific areas, such as serial and family crimes, such as parricides. They fall into a tiny statistic, but they cause a huge social disruption, which is why it is important to study them.

BBC News Brasil — Why are some people averse to discussing crimes?

Casoy — Not everyone can deal with the misery in the world. It turns out that the world is doing a good job of trivializing crime, because there is so much crime news, so detailed, for so many hours on the air, as if it were a Big Brother of crime, that the population can't take it anymore.

BBC News Brasil — There is a punitive mindset gaining strength in the country, calling for mass incarceration. How do you interpret this?

Casoy — I cry. In Brazil, there is no life sentence and, if a person is going to get out of jail, it is better to take good care of them, because our aim is to reintegrate them into society. In countries with life imprisonment, you can let yourself go crazy in your cell and eat plaster; In theory there's no problem, she'll never go back to the community. But our justice system is not like that, so we have to take care of the prisoner.

Another thing: crime in general is not what appears in the media. We are not talking about people who killed their father and mother, killed their daughter or committed serious crimes. The biggest crime is people who stumbled, who made mistakes, who made mistakes. It is still possible for the State to fight for this person. You don't need to believe that whoever made a mistake once fell into an endless pit.

But people want quick results, so this intolerance remains. Ah, let's increase the sentence. I've never seen criminals discuss punishment before committing a crime. Have you ever seen people sit down and say: "Let's see if it's better to rob the store or the bank or people?" There is no such thing. The penalty is irrelevant, because the criminal's identification rate is low. So, there is no point in increasing the penalty. You have to invest in those who will investigate, in the equipment, in the laboratories, in the expertise.

BBC News Brasil — One of the most high-profile cases you worked on was that of Suzane von Richthofen. How did you get into it?

Casoy — I was doing an internship at DHPP, the State Department of Homicide and Personal Protection, and I really wanted to see a simulated reproduction. But they are always dangerous, because you take the killer to the place where the crime was committed and, in general, these are risky places. I was a civilian, no one wanted to take me into the crowd.

When this case happened, it was my chance. When I asked the magistrate judge for permission to watch, she asked why. I said I wanted to write a book about the case. I didn't know when, but I wanted to. I ended up interviewing more than a hundred people, launching the book and, as a result, I was increasingly asked to talk about the case.

Credit, Stella Carvalho/Disclosure

BBC News Brasil — And what was your role in the Netflix documentary?

Casoy — I did criminology consultancy and also brought some people to talk about this crime. I think it's important to discuss. I study the human mind, so I have no prejudice regarding the crime that will be the subject of a documentary. I wanted to hear what she had to say. She was 19 years old when it happened, it's been more than 20 years. I wanted to understand what a person who spent their life in prison thinks, what changed in their mind. That was the goal, right?

BBC News Brasil — What did you discover when watching the interview?

Casoy — I did not have access to the full interview. In fact, a lot of people asked if I interviewed her. No. I'm a criminologist, not a journalist or director. But there were interesting things. For example, [researcher] Cíntia Tucunduva says that Suzane showed the house like a guide to a museum. I expand: to this day she talks about this crime like a guide to a crime museum. She gives a story that is separate from her. That's something that impresses me, how far she has from this crime. [Psychoanalyst] Christian Dunker says that she dissociates, she doesn't take responsibility, she isn't horrified by herself, because it's their fault [the Cravinhos brothers].

Suzane is very strong rationally, but very poor emotionally. She explains everything and even knows when to cry. This is a refined, intellectual understanding, but she gets it, because she's not feeling it. She has a quote from the book to talk about her relationship with her brother: "We were equal, but now there were two dead and a tragedy between us." Man, how strong. The feeling of it was lacking, but the semantics are impeccable. But, if you're going to cry and no tears come out, it's better not to try, right?

She understands intellectually that she is responsible, because she says: "I took them there." But where am I pulling out my hair because I took them there? There's no such part. And she has an addiction: asking "do you understand?" all the time. This is underestimating the person in front of you. Of course I understand. The problem is whether I feel what you are saying.

BBC News Brasil — Knowing the investigation so thoroughly, do you think there were parts that should be explored further in the documentary?

Casoy — There were some parts that were little explored. For example, situational homosexuality. A person who has a long sentence and is heterosexual, both male and female, how do they resolve this issue? Is she homosexual? Suzane had a relationship with someone of the same sex. She talks awkwardly about it. And today she is straight, married to a man, has a son. So she was always heterosexual, but she had situational homosexuality. It was important that this had been explored further.

Another thing I miss is that Suzane had a baby via cesarean section, with a scheduled date, and she chose the date of Daniel Cravinhos' birthday. I would have asked: doesn't it bother you that your son was born on the same day as Daniel?

BBC News Brasil — There are those who say that the interviewer failed to confront her.

Casoy — A confrontation won't happen, because no one will get this interview. Do you think she will agree? Do you think she's going to put her face on camera to be confronted? The role of Lygia [director] and Maká [co-director] is very delicate. They walk on a knife's edge all the time. At any moment this girl gets up and it's over. It's not about cornering her. It takes a lot of skill. So I congratulate the directors very much. It was difficult to decide what to ask, because it's not her judgment. She has already been tried and convicted.

Now, the most important thing we take away is that it is one thing to legally serve your sentence. She will finish complying and, legally, she will be zero for zero. But moral judgment works differently. Will she be morally absolved? There is no law that holds it back.

BBC News Brasil — How do you see the criticism made of the film?

Casoy — I am amazed at the reaction of personal hatred that some people express, both on the Netflix page and on mine. I think: "Guys, why do you feel so betrayed? It wasn't her case with you, right?" Society feels very betrayed by Suzane. Why? It's a white, straight, cool, middle class society, and this girl was one of us. How does she do this? She did, but it wasn't against you, society. It was her problem, right? That's why I think the case gives rise to enormous discussions — psychological, philosophical, social, educational, even biological, if you want. Now, people's reaction is as if she committed a crime against each of them.

What do you think she could have done to redeem herself? Self-torture, self-mutilation? People cannot listen to her report with scientific interest, with impartiality. They feel part of this story and react with a lot of hatred — and hatred against the producer, against those who were interviewed to support this discussion.

A lot of people write: "Why doesn't Netflix make a movie about Professor X?" Netflix is ​​not a charity. You were the ones who gave a stage and an audience to this crime and what is Netflix going to get? Things that already have a stage. It's not charitable. It needs to present a balance sheet, the stock has to rise, there are thousands of questions.

Why isn't there good news in the newspaper? Because nobody wants to hear it. It's easy to say now, but it's you, society, who set the stage for this. So you can't complain that this is what streaming wants to talk about.

I am a professional trying to understand a human mind very different from my own. She didn't cheat on me.

BBC News Brasil — In what sense did you betray?

Casoy — Ah, ela é como a gente. Lamento. Ela é uma menina branca, hétero, que estudava na PUC. Quer mais clichê do que a Suzane? É a filha nota 10. E como isso acontece? Mas a discussão importa. É lógico que não se justifica nada, mas, por exemplo: não adianta proibir um adolescente de namorar com alguém. Não é proibindo que o pai vai educar. "Proíbo você de namorar o Daniel." Beleza, jogou ela no colo do Daniel. Isso justifica? Claro que não. Ninguém deve ser morto. Nem mesmo quem cometeu crime. Agora vamos aprender. Se você consegue se distanciar, você tira conhecimento dali.

Credit, DarkSide Publisher/Disclosure

BBC News Brasil — Her relationship with her father, which you mentioned, is interesting. Was she abused?

Casoy — She denies it, her brother denies it, but Daniel states in great detail that he saw bruises on her. I don't know the truth. She denies it and accuses Daniel of wanting to use this to defend himself. Obviously, if she claimed that she was raped or sexually abused by her father, this story would change angles. You could say she doesn't say that because she already feels so guilty. It is very difficult for the abused to speak, especially in this situation. But we don't know.

Andreas, who is the outside figure, denies anything about this, but several theories have been created. And why are theories created? Because people need to give a very serious reason to justify a crime like this. And sometimes there's no reason.

BBC News Brasil — Suzane says, laughing, that a prosecutor fell in love with her and offered her a snack as a gift. This excerpt is being reproduced on the networks. People say, based on it, that Suzane has some mental complication. Was an exam carried out at the time to say if she had any psychiatric issues?

Casoy — Tests were carried out. I'm not going to go into this area too much because it's very technical. But I can tell you that there was no diagnosis of psychopath. Now, we have to consider the following: [people think that] those who kill can no longer laugh, right? You can't be happy. This accompanies sentencing. The way she is morally condemned, what do you mean you will laugh? Shut up. You're not going to laugh in my face, are you? You won't be happy. What do you mean you got married and have a son? Are you crazy? You don't deserve it.

If I were arrested and taken out at night to be taken to a prosecutor's office to hear a prosecutor, I would be cold with fear. She was not afraid. Isn't it interesting? I find that more interesting. For her, it was funny; For me, it would be scary. But for her it was pathetic. You see how she has a much stronger intellectual understanding than her emotional understanding.

BBC News Brasil — In any case, she does not seem to have been absolved by the public. Or she may have made the documentary just to make money.

Casoy — By the way, let me talk about money. I've never heard of that. It was inside [the production]. I've never heard of Suzane receiving money. I'm not peremptorily saying no, but I didn't have that information. I asked and was always denied. Maybe I was the last to know, right?

But I'm surprised by people's aversion. Society continues to condemn after the sentence. But I agree that making money from one's own crime is something I vehemently disagree with, obviously. In the United States, there is already a law against this. I read this weekend that in Brazil there are some proposals in this regard, that whoever commits a crime cannot gain from the crime itself.

BBC News Brasil — Have you had any conversations with her, have you interviewed her?

Casoy — I never tried. I would only be interested in a confrontational interview, but then I already know the answer, right? Rabbits don't come out of this bush. I don't think she will want to talk, because I believe she has an important psychic defense, as Christian Dunker explains in the documentary. She needs to say that it wasn't up to her to survive psychically. So, she takes herself out of this game. It's not for me, because I'm not going to solve her head. I like the process, because nobody likes the process. It's information, and whoever reads it decides what they think.

What benefit could talking to her bring me? I'm not a psychologist, I'm not a psychiatrist, I couldn't do a mental assessment; There is also nothing more to investigate in the police phase, everything has been clarified. The judicial phase too, she is already serving her sentence. Unless something new comes up, it won't change.

BBC News Brasil — You worked on another parricide case, that of Gil Rugai, accused of killing his father and stepmother, and you are releasing a book about him. What was your contribution in this case?

Casoy — I have a lawyer son, Marcelo Feller, and he was appointed by the Public Defender's Office to defend Gil. I already helped the police, the prosecutor's office, but almost always for the prosecution, right? He asked me: "How about participating in a defense?" I read a very different process than a lawyer, because I don't have legal training. I read it like you read Agatha Christie. For me, it's a story, and so I look for things that pass legally, but don't pass muster with those who read it. I said I would only go if I thought he was innocent. I tell this story, both mine and his, in the book.

I transcribed the jury testimonies in full, because if I edited it, you would say: "Ah, what part did you edit? You helped your son, who helped the defense." No, I left the statements in full. The jury will be the reader. The case has already been judged, and Gil was convicted by four votes to three, which is nothing more than a reasonable doubt. Not even the jurors were able to be sure of one thing or another. So, for me, this has to be reviewed.

[Editor's note: Gil Rugai was sentenced to 33 years and 9 months in prison in 2013, after a popular jury. The crime took place in March 2004, when Rugai was 20 years old. Luiz Carlos Rugai and Alessandra de Fátima Troitino were killed with 11 gunshots in Perdizes, a neighborhood in São Paulo. Between arrests and appeals, Gil served less than 12 years in prison. He was released in August 2024, after the Court granted progression to the open regime.]

BBC News Brasil — What is your assessment of it?

Casoy — He was the only suspect investigated, and he was the perfect suspect. It's not that I had no reason to suspect Gil. He had. Gil is very strange. I know that being strange is not a crime, because otherwise I would be in prison, but it still forms part of popular imagination. The main thing is that the time of the crime was never established. This bothered me a lot, because, when you don't establish the time of the crime, you don't give the defendant the possibility of having an alibi.

Discover more

Watch

End of Watch

Who is the Brazilian author who ended up on the New York Times list of unmissable books

The woman obsessed with crime stories who became the obsession of others after the 'mushroom murder'

Top news

The children who fight in court to erase the names of absent or abusive parents from documents: 'I just want to put an end to this story'

'Society feels betrayed by Suzane von Richthofen' because it sees itself in her, says criminologist Ilana Casoy: 'She was one of us, white, straight, middle class'

Turbulence on flights: why episodes like the JetBlue one in Florida could become more common

read more

Most clicked