The ceasefire between the United States and Iran left Israel on the sidelines and largely curbed its war goals, leading critics of Benjamin Netanyahu to point to a "strategic failure." With his hands tied, the Israeli prime minister intensified his attacks in Lebanon to now accept talks under obvious pressure from the United States.

First modification: 04/10/2026 - 03:31 Last modification: 04/10/2026 - 05:23

To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.

An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spent most of his long political career calling for war against Iran and courting — in vain — successive US presidents until he found a docile ally in Donald Trump.

The war would be quick and rewarding, Netanyahu assured, and would bring about regime change in Iran and the end of its nuclear and ballistic missile programs, as well as lasting glory for the American president.

Instead, five and a half weeks of intensive attacks have produced none of the above, leaving the Israeli leader sidelined as Washington and Tehran prepare for talks in Islamabad after agreeing to a fragile truce.

While the United States and Iran have made similarly grandiose claims of victory, any such talk is likely to ring hollow to an Israeli public that has endured weeks of Iranian counterattacks.

Netanyahu's opponents in their country have spared no reproaches, stressing that Israel has been left aside and that its war objectives have been left up in the air.

"There has never been a political disaster like this in our entire history. Israel was not even close to the table when decisions were made regarding the core of our national security," main Israeli opposition leader Yair Lapid wrote in X.

Read alsoAs Israel continues its brutal attacks, Netanyahu orders "direct negotiations" with Lebanon

“Worse than before the war”

Analysts' assessments have been equally scathing, dismissing attempts to present the assassination of senior Iranian leaders as the advent of a new regime.

"It's somewhere between funny and tragic to hear Washington and Israel claim that the regime has changed," said Yossi Mekelberg, senior fellow at Chatham House's Middle East and North Africa Program.

"Some people have changed, but it is still the same old regime, maybe even worse," he added, noting that the Islamic Republic will feel emboldened after having withstood the joint attack of the world's leading superpower and the most formidable army in the Middle East.

Read alsoLebanon, Strait of Hormuz and other threats facing negotiations: the truce, on the limit

"The regime remains firmly in power. Its missile capabilities are damaged but intact. It still possesses approximately 440 kg of 60% enriched uranium," Danny Citrinowicz, senior Iran researcher at Israel's Institute for National Security Studies, wrote in a post on X.

"At the very least, we must hope that the negotiations in Islamabad will produce a different outcome on the nuclear issue," he added. "Otherwise, we risk coming out of this war worse off than when it started."

Strong armies, weak leadership

The failure of the United States and Israel to translate undeniable battlefield victories into a more favorable outcome reflects the lack of strategic thinking behind a war whose stated objectives seem to have changed with each passing day.

As Citrinowicz wrote, "Tactical successes and operational achievements are almost completely meaningless if they fail to produce a coherent strategic outcome."

Mekelberg noted that strategic failures also reflected a tendency to ignore diplomacy and resort solely to force.

"We are talking about two countries with very strong and capable armies, but also with very weak leadership," he said. "These are leaders who are not very reflective and who, for different reasons, do not understand the world of diplomacy."

In the case of the Israeli prime minister – who faces a lengthy corruption trial and has refused to resign for failing to prevent the October 7, 2023 attacks – the main reason is his own political survival.

"Netanyahu needs an enemy and an open front to stay in power," Mekelberg explained. "But he won't attack Iran again without Trump, so he looked to Lebanon as a place where he could continue."

A 180 degree turn with respect to Lebanon

Contradicting terms set by mediator Pakistan, Israel has insisted that the ceasefire agreed to by Washington and Tehran does not cover Lebanon, where its forces have been fighting Iran-backed Hezbollah for the second time in less than two years.

On Wednesday, hours after Trump's threats to destroy "the entire civilization" of Iran led to a provisional ceasefire, Israel launched its biggest attacks on Lebanon since the start of the war.

The attacks, which spread far beyond Hezbollah's traditional strongholds, killed at least 303 people and injured more than 1,150, according to health authorities, sparking chaos and carnage in central Beirut and threatening to torpedo the fragile truce with Iran, Hezbollah's sponsor.

Read alsoNetanyahu announces talks with Lebanon, but without ceasefire; US to host talks

Although it is quite possible that Netanyahu's goal was precisely to thwart the ceasefire, the Israeli prime minister was forced to give in the next day under pressure from Washington. In an unexpected move, he ordered his ministers to enter into direct negotiations with the Government of Lebanon, focusing on disarming Hezbollah and establishing peace.

"In light of Lebanon's repeated requests to engage in direct negotiations with Israel, yesterday I ordered the cabinet to begin direct negotiations with Lebanon as soon as possible," Netanyahu said in a statement.

Hezbollah lawmaker Ali Fayyad said Thursday that the group rejected direct negotiations with Israel and that the Lebanese government should demand a ceasefire as a precondition before taking any additional steps.

Israel's apparent change of course came after a phone call with the White House, and came just hours after Netanyahu said his country would "continue to attack Hezbollah where necessary." It was not immediately clear whether Israel would agree to cease its attacks on Hezbollah targets before the talks, which a source familiar with the plans said could begin next week.

"Israel has good reason to claim that Hezbollah must be dismantled as a military force. But the question, as always, is how it is going to do it," Mekelberg said. "The situation in Lebanon will not be resolved by force alone."

"Eternal war"

Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz has compared the devastation caused in large areas of southern Lebanon to the scorched earth policy applied against Hamas in the Gaza Strip, which left entire cities depopulated.

Analysts say the creation of "buffer zones" in Gaza, Syria and now Lebanon reflects a strategic shift following the October 7 attacks, one that places Israel in a semi-permanent state of war.

"Israel's leaders have come to the conclusion that they are in an eternal war against adversaries who must be intimidated and even dispersed," said Nathan Brown, of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, in an interview with the Reuters agency.

Instead of addressing Israel's legitimate security concerns, such thinking only aggravates them, Mekelberg argued, lamenting Israel's failure to "translate tactical achievements into diplomatic engagement."

He was skeptical that that mentality would change after the October elections, noting that Netanyahu's critics offer no alternative to Israel "living by the sword."

"The criticism coming from the opposition does not offer a different vision for Gaza, the West Bank or Lebanon," he said. "What they say is that we entered a war and we didn't end it."

Reaction in Washington?

Netanyahu's U-turn on Thursday came after growing international condemnation of the Beirut massacre, and as Germany, his close ally, warned that the "gravity" of Israel's attacks in Lebanon threatened to jeopardize talks between Washington and Tehran.

Although Israel has become largely "immune" to international rejection, Mekelberg noted that the repercussions of the war with Iran on the United States were a very different matter.

"Trump was elected on a promise to end wars and lower the cost of living, and now look at what's happening," he said, adding that war with Iran "could lead to a rethink in Washington and the search for scapegoats, including perhaps the relationship with Israel."

Read alsoNetanyahu sees the truce with Iran as temporary and warns that Israel could resume fighting

Amos Harel, military affairs correspondent for the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, said American media accounts of Israel's role in persuading Trump to seek regime change in Iran could deal a "hard blow to Israel's standing in Washington."

He also suggested that Netanyahu had reason to worry about his personal relationship with the US president.

"Trump doesn't like to lose, and he certainly doesn't like to admit defeat," Harel wrote. "If the campaign against Iran comes to be seen as a failure in the United States, it will look for someone to blame."

Adapted from its original in English.

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.