Negotiations that were decided following the truce concluded between the United States, Israel and Iran last Wednesday will begin Saturday in the Pakistani capital, Islamabad. But fundamental questions, about the composition of delegations, the agenda and the goals of each party, remain without a clear answer. Will this ruin everything?

Published on: 04/10/2026 - 16:46 Last updated: 04/11/2026 - 11:17

To view this content from YouTube, it is necessary to allow the collection of viewing rates and YouTube ads.

It appears that an application in your internet browser is preventing the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must cancel its use.

After the spread of the term “fog of war,” will the fragile truce concluded between the United States, Israel, and Iran, on Wednesday, April 8, lead to the emergence of a new concept, “diplomatic fog”? The features of the upcoming negotiations are still very vague, while these decisive discussions are supposed to begin on Saturday in Islamabad.

Which countries are represented in these negotiations, for what purposes, and on what negotiating grounds? There are many questions for which there is no clear answer, which is what the American network CNN described as a “confusing” situation.

Guarantees that Iranians will not be assassinated

The Iranian embassy in Pakistan had initially announced the arrival of the Iranian delegation to Islamabad on Thursday evening via the X platform, before quickly deleting the message, noting that some “problems” had occurred.

It seems that the Americans have their own problems as well... even in the makeup of their negotiating team.

The delegation is scheduled to be led by Vice President J.D. Vance, but Donald Trump has raised doubts about his presence in Islamabad for “security” reasons. While the authorities of the Pakistani capital announced that the coming days will be an official holiday in Islamabad. Although no specific reason was given, this measure is often given for security reasons before important diplomatic events.

Read also: Mojtaba Khamenei confirms that Iran does not want war, but will defend its rights “under any circumstances”

Scott Lucas, a specialist in US security and foreign policy issues at Ireland's College Dublin, believes that "at this stage, even before asking what will be discussed there, it is legitimate to question the conduct of these negotiations themselves."

A point of view shared by Walter Busch, an Iranian specialist at the Institute for Peacekeeping and Conflict Management of the Austrian Academy of National Defense. But for him, one of the first hurdles to overcome concerns the Iranian delegation, which “will need assurance from the United States that its members will not be assassinated by Israel,” according to this expert.

Iranians, who have previously been exposed to snakebites, may now be afraid of rope, as they say: Israel killed several members of a Hamas delegation that the United States brought to Qatar for negotiations in September 2025.

Even if Pakistan appears less vulnerable to Israeli strikes than Qatar, “one of the first things the Americans will have to do is publicly confirm that Iranian negotiators are not or no longer on Israel’s target list,” admits Scott Lucas.

If the safety of the Iranians can be guaranteed, “the glimmer of hope for this stage of the negotiations is that both sides want the fighting to stop,” asserts Walter Busch.

10 or 15 point agenda?

However, good faith is not enough. It is necessary to know the basis on which negotiations will take place. Here too, between the 15-point proposal that Washington presented to Tehran, Iran's 10-point plan, and Donald Trump's statements, it is difficult to know which direction will be taken.

Reconciling the initial American proposal with Iranian demands would be an achievement. Mehrzad Boroujerdi, an Iranian specialist and dean of the College of Arts, Sciences and Education at the University of Missouri, admits that “the two sides’ views are currently very far apart.”

Read also: Washington will host negotiations between Israel and Lebanon next week to discuss a ceasefire

For Scott Lucas, what is more likely is that Americans stumbled upon Trump's statements. The US President “started out by saying that the 10-point plan presented by Iran was an acceptable negotiating basis, but since then, White House advisors have intensified their efforts to move away from it, because it actually does not suit Washington,” this expert estimates.

“The fact that Donald Trump referred to the Iranian proposal makes it very likely that it will serve as a framework for negotiations in one form or another,” Mehrzad Boroujerdi expects.

Even if the Iranians and Americans agree on the agenda, there is no guarantee that things will go well after that. There are many opportunities to disrupt conversations. For example, if the Americans assert that the Israeli attack on Lebanon has no place at the negotiating table, “the Iranians will most likely leave quickly, because they cannot accept betraying Hezbollah in this way,” asserts Walter Bush.

This does not mean that the fate of the pro-Iranian armed movement in Lebanon cannot be discussed, as experts contacted by France 24 confirm. But “the price that the Americans will pay will be very high and may relate, among other things, to the issue of lifting all sanctions on Iran,” Mehrzad Boroujerdi supports.

J.D. Vance: The right man for the situation?

It's all in Donald Trump's "art of the deal." In other words, it is a matter of men and the way negotiations are conducted. In this regard, Mehrzad Boroujerdi believes that “the presence of J.D. Vance at the head of the American delegation is somewhat good, because he was not very supportive of this war from the beginning.”

Nor were the Iranians keen to face just Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner again. Donald Trump's special envoy to the Middle East and the US President's son-in-law did not impress their interlocutors in Tehran in 2025 during negotiations over the Iranian nuclear program. The failure of those discussions later led to the massive US bombing of nuclear sites in Iran in June 2025.

But Scott Lucas is keen to point out that J.D. Vance is “rather a forced choice for Donald Trump.” The American president does not actually have many options to frame the Witkopf-Kushner duo, “because Secretary of State Marco Rubio has no desire to get involved in this file, and because the president expelled senior experts in the region from the State Department before the war,” as this specialist explains.

This does not mean that there is no longer anyone in the American administration who knows Iran. Mehrzad Boroujerdi believes that “there are experts in other ministries, such as defense and national security, who can offer their expertise.”

On the other hand, the Iranian delegation will be headed by Mohammad Bagher Qalibaf, Speaker of Parliament. Walter Busch considers that "this is a fairly reasonable option for starting negotiations." The former mayor of Tehran, often described as a “hawk” of the regime and at the same time a pragmatist, was a candidate to be one of Washington’s potential interlocutors favored by Donald Trump.

The importance of his presence at the head of the Iranian delegation lies in the fact that, because he is a military man close to the Revolutionary Guards, “he can also be a bridge with those who are opposed to the negotiations in Iran,” adds Walter Busch.

However, he is not a career diplomat, and this expert asserts that “when it comes to dealing with the details of a more comprehensive peace agreement, Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi will have to play a more central role.”

Therefore, the negotiations that are about to begin are only the beginnings, according to the experts heard by FRANCE 24. A first stage that will be difficult indeed, but it is far from resolving anything and everything. This possibility may not appeal to the US President, who is often hasty in his desire to achieve quick results.

French text: Sébastien Saibet | Arabic text: Hussein Amara

Keywords related to the article

The content you want to browse is no longer in service or is currently unavailable.